Chamber of Secrets

Chamber of Secrets (http://www.cosforums.com/index.php)
-   Muggle Studies (http://www.cosforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=21)
-   -   Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series (http://www.cosforums.com/showthread.php?t=131701)

Halcipher September 9th, 2012 4:22 am

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Best: Daniel Radcliffe and David Thewlis. :D
Gambon and Fiennes
Gambon and Daniel (Kings Cross Scene)
James and Oliver!

Worst: Bonnie Wright and Daniel Radcliffe,
I saw no sparks whatsoever, they were hugely boring together. I forget that they are even in a relationship when I watch the movie.

RebeccaMatthews September 9th, 2012 5:35 am

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
I never felt there was much of a connection with Bonnie and many of the cast members. She reminded me much of Kristen Stewart once I became familiar with her (Kristen) acting.

The best, IMO, was Dan, Rupert and Emma. I thought the three of them worked really well together.

Richard_G. September 9th, 2012 6:40 am

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Another coupling to mention, which I'm surprised slipped me - Dan and Evanna. If I tentatively shipped Harry and Luna after OOTP, it's solely because they felt so natural together - two outcasts who really understood each other.

StarsAndShadows September 9th, 2012 7:42 am

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Richard_Gambon (Post 6038366)
Another coupling to mention, which I'm surprised slipped me - Dan and Evanna. If I tentatively shipped Harry and Luna after OOTP, it's solely because they felt so natural together - two outcasts who really understood each other.

Oh, I forgot about Luna and Harry! Yes, Dan and Evanna worked well together. I remember when I went to see the movie, someone in the audience, who apparently hadn't read the book wondered why Harry Potter was "kissing the Chinese girl instead of the blonde girl". :lol:

snapes_witch September 9th, 2012 7:48 am

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
In defence of Dan's and Bonnie's casting we must remember they were children with no one having any idea what Harry's and Ginny's future was going to be (except JKR). A romance was far in the future with no hint of that in the four books published at the time the first movie went into production.

Montse September 9th, 2012 10:04 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by StarsAndShadows (Post 6038369)
Oh, I forgot about Luna and Harry! Yes, Dan and Evanna worked well together. I remember when I went to see the movie, someone in the audience, who apparently hadn't read the book wondered why Harry Potter was "kissing the Chinese girl instead of the blonde girl".

Something similar happened at my theatre, this girl in behind me was saying something about Harry not supposed to end with Hermione but with this new weird girl :lol:

Warlock27 September 10th, 2012 10:17 am

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
This is why people need to read the books. Then they wouldn't allow the movies to mislead them.

I really don't give a flying snitch who had the better chemistry. Staying true to the source material was more important.

Apheka September 10th, 2012 1:19 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
I loved all the scenes with Richard Harris and Dan in the first two movies.
It's a shame we'll never know how the two would have interacted with each other in the later films.

I have to join the Bonnie and Dan club, no chemistry at all when there should have been.

Goddess_Clio September 10th, 2012 6:14 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by snapes_witch (Post 6038370)
In defence of Dan's and Bonnie's casting we must remember they were children with no one having any idea what Harry's and Ginny's future was going to be (except JKR). A romance was far in the future with no hint of that in the four books published at the time the first movie went into production.

That is definitely a good point and something that does need to be kept in mind.

I almost want to say that I don't care, though. As an actor your job isn't just to say the words on the page, it's also to deliver them believable, to make the audience care, to interact with costars in a believable and convincing way. Though, yes, Dan and Bonnie were cast with no clue as to their future romance, I'm still disappointed that they couldn't come up with more than the awkward, flat performances they gave.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warlock27 (Post 6038632)
I really don't give a flying snitch who had the better chemistry. Staying true to the source material was more important.

The movies stayed true to the source material where Harry and Ginny were concerned and look what we got: Painful to watch interactions of Dand and Bonnie trying to flirt and kiss.

Personally, knowing what we know now of how Dan and Bonnie interact in those kissy moments, I would have accepted a Harry/Luna pairing in the movies knowing Dan and Evanna had way better chemistry. It wouldn't have been canon, wouldn't have stayed true to source material but I wouldn't have to cringe away from the screen every time Harry and his love interest made eyes at each other.

wolfbrother September 10th, 2012 9:33 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by snapes_witch (Post 6038370)
In defence of Dan's and Bonnie's casting we must remember they were children with no one having any idea what Harry's and Ginny's future was going to be (except JKR). A romance was far in the future with no hint of that in the four books published at the time the first movie went into production.

This is one of the reasons I think that movies based on a series should be done after the series is completed.

mrfutterman September 10th, 2012 10:41 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Warlock27 (Post 6038632)
This is why people need to read the books. Then they wouldn't allow the movies to mislead them.

Mislead them, how? That something in the films differs slightly from something in the novels doesn't matter to anybody except a tiny handful of fans. Nobody "needs" to read the books.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warlock27 (Post 6038632)
I really don't give a flying snitch who had the better chemistry. Staying true to the source material was more important.

So why are you posting on a thread with the title: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series?

Not much to add to what others have said; Dan and Bonnie were a lifeless couple.

Harry's interaction with his various father figures - Dumbledore, Sirius, Lupin - was well done.

Quote:

Originally Posted by wolfbrother (Post 6038733)
This is one of the reasons I think that movies based on a series should be done after the series is completed.

This was a decision for the author. Can we please grant her the courtesy of allowing her to act in her own best interests?

Montse September 10th, 2012 11:18 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
I am not going to defend Bonnie and Dan , but lets take into consideration the scenes they gave them were not precisely " good ".

I mean tying Harry´s shoelace , or having him zip her dress up? I wish they had had better moments like they did in the book,if those did not work on screen ,think of other ones, but this ones they came up with were pretty lame. I do think part of the lack of chemistry is a consequence of the silly scenes they gave them. They might have worked more if there had been a spark between them, but even so, what they were supposed to perform was lacking the mood or something. They simply were no good.

Dedalus Diggle September 10th, 2012 11:26 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Let's give kudos to the Dursleys - loathesome as they were. Which is just the point, right?

StarsAndShadows September 11th, 2012 5:06 am

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dedalus Diggle (Post 6038771)
Let's give kudos to the Dursleys - loathesome as they were. Which is just the point, right?

Absolutely! The interaction between them and Harry is just right too. Ditto Dudley. And let's not forget Aunt Marge, little as we see her. Hers and Harry's mutual contempt and loathing for each other came across rather well.

MsJPotter September 11th, 2012 1:30 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

mrfutterman;6038758]Mislead them, how? That something in the films differs slightly from something in the novels doesn't matter to anybody except a tiny handful of fans. Nobody "needs" to read the books.
Well I think they do if they want to know the actual story of Harry Potter. The movies, IMO are glorified fan fiction. In fact I've read fan fiction that was better than the movie scripts. As for posting in this thread, well I am posting in this thread because IMO if the films had stuck even a little bit to the actual storyline that was in the books instead of inventing 60-75% of what we saw in screen, then we might just have got better chemistry and better movies. Bad chemistry quite often is a result of a bad script and 'The Half Blood Prince' and DH2 is IMO, the proof of that pudding.

StarsAndShadows September 11th, 2012 8:11 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MsJPotter (Post 6038902)
Well I think they do if they want to know the actual story of Harry Potter. The movies, IMO are glorified fan fiction. In fact I've read fan fiction that was better than the movie scripts.

I agree on all three statements. :agree:

I never thought of it that way but yes, with all the changes, the movies are fan fics, and not very good fan fics at that.

I particularly hated that scene where Snape holds Lily's dead body while baby Harry is bawling his heart out, and Snape doesn't even spare him a glance. I don't know why they put that scene in. Whoever wrote it must not have read the books. It's not at all canon. Snape was not in Godric's Hollow that night. The only people on the scene, just after the Potters' murder, were Sirius and Hagrid - that's when Sirius lent his motorcycle to Hagrid to carry Harry to the Dursleys'. How would Snape have known to be there anyway? I don't see either Pettigrew or Voldemort telling him. :shrug:

Quote:

Bad chemistry quite often is a result of a bad script and 'The Half Blood Prince' and DH2 is IMO, the proof of that pudding.
Absolutely.

Verena September 11th, 2012 8:31 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by StarsAndShadows (Post 6038966)
I particularly hated that scene where Snape holds Lily's dead body while baby Harry is bawling his heart out, and Snape doesn't even spare him a glance. I don't know why they put that scene in. Whoever wrote it must not have read the books. It's not at all canon. Snape was not in Godric's Hollow that night. The only people on the scene, just after the Potters' murder, were Sirius and Hagrid - that's when Sirius lent his motorcycle to Hagrid to carry Harry to the Dursleys'. How would Snape have known to be there anyway? I don't see either Pettigrew or Voldemort telling him. :shrug:

Me too. I can’t stand these inventions that their put in the movies that have nothing to do with the books.

mrfutterman September 11th, 2012 9:15 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Thread topic, anybody?

The additional Snape/Lily material was very good indeed: better than anything the author wrote.

I quite liked the dynamic between Voldemort and Bellatrix, while wishing for more but the film-makers were too timid to adapt thoroughly, so too often we get soggy veg instead of dramatic meat.

StarsAndShadows September 11th, 2012 11:06 pm

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrfutterman (Post 6038975)
Thread topic, anybody?

The additional Snape/Lily material was very good indeed: better than anything the author wrote.

Even if it wasn't canon? :hmm: OK maybe to some it's good fan fic. I'd rather stick to canon, and, I repeat, Snape was not on the scene at Godric's Hollow. He could not have been.

Well, back to thread topic - I didn't see any chemistry between Snape and Lily's dead body, nor did I see any between Snape and the infant he totally ignored. Isn't tending to the needs of the living, especially a baby, more important than holding the dead? A dead woman who liked you once but never did love you?

ShadowSonic September 12th, 2012 12:18 am

Re: Best and Worst Chemistry in the HP Series
 
Well, grief can sort of mess with your mind for a while...


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 2:06 am.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2020, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

Original content is Copyright © MMII - MMVIII, CoSForums.com. All Rights Reserved.
Other content (posts, images, etc) is Copyright © its respective owners.