Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
I'm just all for the pan up :lol:
ALTHOUGH (I seem to be saying this alot tonight) Reading what you said just gave me a thought that sent shivers up my spine. How about the entire time that they dialogue between Harry and Dumbledore is happening their backs are turned to the castle. So while all the 'I need Severus" and stuff is happening the audience see's the Dark Mark floating over the school in the distance. That would be CRAZY! Then Harry looks back and alerts Dumbledore..yadda yadda To give you a visual reference...kinda like when Cedric and Harry were pulled to the graveyard. Just imagine that building in the background of that scene is Hogwarts with the Dark Mark and Cedric is Dumbledore....wow Although I still want my pan though :lol: THAT could possibly make me change my mind because I can see the audience reaction while Harry and Dumbledore are clueless. Good idea MoD!! *Starts pondering next HBP script rewrite* |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
No problem my friend.
Hey, It's me :cool: That's actually exactly what I had in mind. That the audience would see the mark and the suspense would be that the characters don't know. It's like one of those classic: "BEHIND YOU!!!" moments in the old horror films. I can't wait for the rewrite! Don't forgot to include my own lines in the begining when Harry and Dumbledore are walking to Slughorn's house: DUMBLEDORE Stay vigilant, Harry. I give you every right to use any jinx, hex or spell that comes to mind if you need to defend yourself. These are dangerous times. HARRY Alright, but I can't say I'm too worried, sir. DUMBLEDORE Oh? And why not? Harry is now very arkward and shy. HARRY Er...well....I am with you. Dumbledore laughs. DUMBLEDORE Ah, Harry you make it so hard to be modest.... Harry smiles DUMBLEDORE Even so..it won't hurt to keep an eye out, hmm? *serious and grave now* Some evil in this world is beyond even me, Harry. That's what your revised scirpt needs. More ADAPTATION. Alot of your lines are only taken from the book. Be creative. Add some new life to the scirpt. Make up your own lines keeping to the canon and nature of the character of course but don't be afraid to be creative. Keep up the good work! :tu: |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Thanks and I'll surely add those lines (To your credit of course) and you're right.
I really didn't want to go into hardcore adaptation mode until I saw OOTP though you know? Now that I have in my mind what I want to do (And I know the ending of the series YAY) I'll be able to really get in and try to make it my own (But keeping the feeling right) You've inspired me to start rewriting HBP (I'll finish DH soon enough..there's SO much I need to change in HBP first) So when I wake up the rewriting will begin. Also since I'm tired and there have been a number of posts since earlier I'll just go ahead and post the ending of my HBP script. It's been a long journey but it only took 8 pages for me to make it here. Thanks to everyone in this thread who has given me opinions and I'll be using them next time. Where's ArryGrotter? You should get back in here and stop having a 'real' life :lol: Anyways here's the ending to the third version of my HBP script....4th version starts tomorrow and hopefully there will be interest to read it when I'm done. Quote:
Thanks for reading everyone :) Also here's a list of everything I cut out for anyone who cares (And notice how OFF I was on some very IMPORTANT things that I thought wasn't needed) CUTS: -MUNDUNGUS FLETCHER -FINAL QUIDDITCH MATCH -LUNA’S COMMENTARY -BUCKBEAK -ELABORATION OF TONKS AND LUPINS RELATIONSHIP (THERE ARE CLUES) -RON BEING TRICKED TO THINK HE TOOK FELIX FELICES -RONS VICTORY IN QUIDDITCH -THE PRIME MINISTER -HAGRIDS ANGER TOWARDS THE TRIO NOT TAKING HIS CLASS -FRED AND GEORGE’S JOKE PENS -HARRY TRYING TO GET INTO THE ROOM OF REQUIRMENTS TO SEE WHAT DRACO IS UP TOO -SNAPE TELLING HARRY TO BRING HIS BOOKS TO HIM (AFTER THE DRACO FIGHT) -HARRY THROWING THE ADVANCED POTIONS BOOK INTO THE ROOM OF REQUIREMENTS AFTER HARMING DRACO -DRACO LEAVING QUIDDITCH GAME WITH TWO “GIRLS” THAT ARE REALLY CRABBE AND GOYLE IN DISQUISE -ARAGOG’S FUNERAL -HERBOLOGY CLASS -HAGRID AT DIAGON ALLEY -HARRY’S DISCUSSION WITH MCGONNAGALL AFTER DUMBLEDORE’S DEATH IN DUMBLEDORE’S OFFICE -SPINNERS END -THE MEMORY WHEN TOM RIDDLE MEETS MORFIN GAUNT -CHARMS CLASS -FLUER DELACOUR (SHE IS OF COURSE MENTIONED….SHE’S SACRAFICED FOR BILL WEASLEY INSTEAD) -DUMBLEDORE AND HARRY VISITING SLUGHORN AND CONVINCING HIM TO WORK AT HOGWARTS |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Thanks for posting the end!
I was going to point out alot of mistakes but since you reminded us how long ago this was made, I won't. Let me just say Bill and Fleur have no place in this film in my opinion. I'm happy you are going to use my lines in your script! I'm honored. :) Another little note: One of Ginny's character traits is she never cries. It is what Harry loves about her. I would cut her crying if it was me. Interesting about adding the bit where we see Dumbledore's office with his portrait though I really feel strongly that the film should cut right from Harry finding Dumbledore's body to a montage and then the funeral. Hermione and Luna explaning what happened during the battle is not nessesary though I do love your idea for voice overs and your characterizations are spot on. After Dumbledore is killed and Harry is chasing the death eaters through the castle, I wouldn' have any dialog. I'd have the music and battle sounds take over the soundtrack and segue into a fast paced decent down through the castle following the battles here and there. I would keep Greyback attacking Harry though, what a frightning bit! And Harry and Ginny saving each other is cute. I imagine a free fall dropping camera pan down through the room with many moving staircases with people fighting on the stairs and bodies falling down, the paitnings screaming and dodging spells as the camera would zoom down down down to the bottom where we see Snape and co running out of Hogwarts followed by Harry hot on their heels. Let me make another suggestion about the revelation of Eileen Prince. I wouldn't have Hermione telling us all about it but Snape during his and Harry's duel: SNAPE Not everyone are so PROUD of their fathers, Potter! Not I. I am the Half-Blood Prince! I invented those spells you used against me! :lol: about the Kloves thing with Hermione! Good work :tu: I can't wait to read the revised script and I'm flattered to hear I've inspired you. That means alot to me. btw, 'real' life is overrated. :relax: |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Phrozenone,
Amazing, great work. I only read a couple parts that you posted, but I gotta say I loved you take on the Sectumsempra scene and the entire ending portion. You cut some stuff out but kept the essentials. If the movie is anything like your portions of the script that I read I think we're in for a great one. :drool: One thing I really liked about the DD death scene was that you just had him falling backwards off the tower rather than being blasted into the air and falling off like Jo described. I felt this was a slip up on her part because every other time AK is seen they just go limp suddenly. In fact when I read that scene in the book, I thought for sure DD wasn't dead because they spell didn't perform like AK and figured that it was a set up faked death and Snape didn't mean to harm which is required for the unforgivable curses or simply said a non-verbal spell as well that acted diffently. But the wait you described it left no doubt in my mind that he was dead. Great job. I'm so excited for this film. And thanks for posting your take on HBP Phrozenone. That must have taken a long time to put together! |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Ironicly, I felt differently about Dumbledore's death. I think that the way it is portayed in the book will make better cinema because it's a visual idea and it's full of symbolism.
I think Jo Rowling being a Christan framed Dumbledore's death at least subconciously to mirror that of Christ metaphoricly. One of Christ's disciples Judas betrayed Jesus and led to him being crucified. In a similar fashion (at least within the self contained story of HBP alone) Snape betrays Dumbledore to his death leading to Dumbledore's christlike posture before he falls off the tower. I'm not a Christian myself but that imagery is just too powerful to abanden in a film. Who cares if the AK curse dosen't lift people up? In the movies, Cedric was BLASTED back and Sirius was slowly pushed back. Sometimes the drama must overtake the logic in the films and at the same time it is adhering to the canon and what Jo Rowling intended in my opinion. |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Quote:
I also came to that conclusion mainly because I didn't want to believe Dumbledore was dead. It's the same way I felt after Sirius died, I was like what the heck he only passed through a veil, he's not dead! |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Thank you both so much :)
Funny story this script...if we're talking a page a minuete like they do the real world....equals a minuet shorter than COS :lol: So I have to cut it down ALOT. I have a few ideas though...hopefully once they're posted (My goal is to get the whole thing up before HBP is released) you'll be excited about them as I was when I thought about them. I'm also going to challenge myself a bit this time around. I'm actually going to go with what I THINK they're doing with the actual movie and keep it to 3 (maybe) 4 memories and see is it possible to make sense of everything (Yes that means no Gaunts...but trust me guys...something I thought of last night may blow your minds :p) It's going to be very different than this one and much shorter hopefully. It's amazing because I'm now on my 4th draft and each one has been SO different. That just goes to show that there are many ways to interpret these books (And now knowing the ending changes ALOT of things) Well I'm off to writing and thank you all SO much for your input because seeing what others think and feel about it helps alot. And MoD you're the 2nd person to mention to me that about Ginny. I think I had her cry in my DH script (A few pages back if you want to read it...actually...you must...I'm REALLY interested in what you think of that) after Hedwigs Death...so no more tears for Ginny. Jeez :lol: |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Quote:
What's wrong with being as long as Chamber of Secrets. I think 2.5 hrs. would be the perfect time for all the Harry Potter movies save maybe GoF and of course DH. So my opinion would be to cut about 10 min. if it's 160 min., not sure if this is what you meant? Also, Chamber of Secrets seemed too long because it had too many filler scenes. As MasterOfDeath mentioned, CoS has the best deleted scenes for example. I believe some of these should have been left in while other material that made the final cut should not have. Well, that just my opinion. I look forward to reading the revised script, that'll be interesting to try and predict what Kloves is doing! EDIT: I mentioned this on on the HBP thread but I'll put it here too if you didn't see it. I was just reading another few portions of your HBP script and there are a few things that I really loved, altough I think I was reading your first draft so I don't know if these have changed: - First, I almost kind of like how you left out Spinner's End, it give's it more mystery. But taking the actors into consideration, I think this is too great of an oppurtunity to leave out a scene between Helena and Rickman!!! - Second, I love how you introduced Slughon quickly and effectively on the train as this saves a lot of time for more important items. Even though I thought the book scene was cool I think it is wasted in the film! - Second, the DADA scene with Snape is spot on perfection just like in the book. I love where Harry is a smartass and says, "There's no need to call me sir" This must stay in the film!!! You know Rickman will make this scene great in his interaction with Harry! - Last, Potions class was awesome too. It was short, maybe 2-3 min. but it had the essentials. Only one thing I noticed. You should have thrown in a line or scene where Slughorn hands Harry and Ron the Potions books out of the cupboard. You see, you had Slughorn mention borrowing ingredients but not books. This made is seem really abrupt when all of sudden we see Harry reading scribbled things in the margins and it's like wait a minute, I thought Harry never bought a book? and why is it written it? Well, that's all. Great Job, it's fantastic! :tu: :tu: :tu: |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Thanks Icbaseball22 :) Well needless to say this new one I'm writing is going to be opposite since I want to see how many ways I can write it so I'll be included the trip to Slughorn's home this time.
For a special treat I will post what I've done today for you all. It's not much and I'm ready for the criticism. Just playing with idea's at the moment..trying to release my inner Kloves :lol: As I said before I'm going to try and take out what we know they've taken out (Or think they have) in the actually HBP movie and see can I make them work. You'll see pretty soon what's missing. Hope you enjoy and if you don't then let me know! Quote:
|
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Phrozenone, I'm so sorry I didn't look at your third-act HBP stuff sooner, but wow, very nicely done! :tu: I mean, there are things I would/will do differently in mine, of course, and some stage directions and dialogue that needs touching up, but you've done a really good job (on the whole as well). I look forward to the next draft. I'm probably way outmatched here. :D I don't have the time to pick at everything right now, but I'll go through your Spinner's End later tonight, or tomorrow morning; I just wanted to give a complimentary overview now.
:clap: (Real lives are overrated, by the way. :lol:) |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Okay, Phrozenone, I will try not to think of what version of what is better when reading our HBP drafts. :lol: You're really off to a great start, and I look forward to more. It's good to read your Spinner's End and Horace Slughorn, not only because the previous draft didn't have them, but also because I see that we both took the same crucial points of the scenes without doing the same thing. It seems MasterOfDeath, lcbaseball22, and I may be replacing ArryGrotter for the moment, so I'll just point out a few details now:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
So, yeah, this is a fine start. :tu: |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Thanks IenjoyAcidPops and what u said is so true. Every single one of us can take this one story and make each script entirely different. That's what I love about it. Thanks for your input :)
Now this next section was hard from me. I actually got writers black (Is that possible :lol:) but I'm happy with the outcome so let me know what you think. Quote:
|
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Excellent Phrozenone!
I love how you added Snape coming to fetch Harry this time, I knew there was something missing in your last one but I couldn't remember. In addition, an extra scene with Alan Rickman is never a bad thing. Now, just a few constructive criticisms: - I could be wrong, but I believe if Kloves keeps the WWW Joke shop scene the whole point of it would be to show the Dark Arts and Defense products such as the Peruvian Instant Darkness Powder, the Shield Attire, and the Decoy Detonators. At least that is what I would like to see if this scene is in. I do love how you kept the U-NO-POO sign though, it's just too good to cut. I laughed so hard when I read that in the book. :lol: - Even though Auror ambitions haven't been mentioned in the movie, I found it somewhat strange that you had a line where Harry says, "And look at this…we don’t have to take Potions anymore. No more Snape…this day is great already!" just because in the book he was disappointed he wasn't going to be able to take NEWT potions since it was required if he was to be an Auror. Also, It would be nice to throw in a line that says Hermione got 11 Owls/all but one Outstanding to emphasize again "she is the best in their year" because she just responded "Oh, all right" and we don't see what she really got. - I'm not so sure about the over-emphasis on the "Vanishing Cabinet" although I guess it's good for the idiots who don't read the books. - I guess it's just too hard for me to not compare to the books but I find it odd that Harry was surprised and didn't know where Fred and George were considering he gave them the money to start their business! Overall though, very very good. :tu: :tu: :tu: By the way, for each of your versions, approx. how long would the film be? |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Plus it's the whole 'show don't tell thing' I realized when I posted the Astronomy Tower scene that Draco just mentioning 'Oh there are two Vanishing Cabinets' didn't really hit me like I wanted it too you know? Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
As I said before the last one was about 163 mins long (Since...technically...a page equals a minuete) So far it has taken me 34 minuets to get to Hogwarts :lol: We're hear now so let the fun begin :D |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Alright everyone I will now post the next part of version 4 of my HBP script. You will notice ALOT of changes in this one. I was trying to figure out what scene to follow up Dumbledore's Speech with and i remembered that they filmed a scene with McGonagall telling Harry about his classes so I put that in. I opened with Neville since he doesnt have much to do and I like this little moment between him and McGonagall. Also you will get to see the first memory and I really hope you all like what I did with it. If not...well I like it :p Anyways I'll shut up now and as always your comments and criticism is welcomed :)
Warning. This is a long one :lol: Quote:
|
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Phrozenone, that was incredible, pure genious! You tied up the loose ends very well. I love how you threw the Auror ambition in there, Harry apologizing to Cho, Sirius' Will, and Dumbledore explaining about Trelawny (was this in the book? I see now that Trelawny is not neccessary as some are suggesting. Just have DD relay the info to Harry and that Snape is the one to overhear.)
Thanks for taking my advice and adding to the Potions scene and the Half-Blood Prince book. It was brilliant! :tu: Not sure if this is possible, I don't know if you changed anything but the DADA scene with Snape seemed even better than last draft!!! Yes, I think what you did with the first memory was awesome! :tu: Did we see Nagini in the book? (It's been too long, I can't remember) Quote:
Sorry, I unfortunately don't have any criticism for you this time. It was great. Let's just hope Kloves does it similar. It's too bad you're not our scriptwriter! |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Ginny and Harry get together long before the end of DH and she is invoilved in the final action with him and secrets are revealed about her that effect the final outcome of the story....haha
I just made all of that up IDK what I would like alot of things.. |
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
Quote:
Sorry it's taken me so long to reply. You thought I'd forgotten about your statement about the Potions book huh :p I changed the DADA scene a bit actually (also it's further back than originally) and I like it. Nagini wasn't there in the book it was one of those things I added because I thought it would add to the scene (Plus we get to see a Horcrux :D) I'm glad you like the memory though because I was really trying to make it flow...but not drag...and really show how disturbed little Tom Riddle was. Also I made an Edit to the scene in Borgin and Burke's and I have the trio now bumping into a shelf..which in turn holds the very necklace that will come into play later. I thought I should introduce it now instead of having the audience try to think back to Harry seeing it his 2nd year (Did that make it in the film? I think it was a deleted scene) I will be posting the next section very soon. I've taken some time off to really think through how I want the next section to go (Seeing as Quidditch Tryouts are coming up and I've always been afraid to actually write out Quidditch :lol:) Thanks for reading my script though I REALLY appreciate it and as an added treat the next section will be longer (To make up for the time I've missed :)) Hmmm well I take it back I guess I'll be posting today instead :lol: I'm not sure if it's as long as I wanted but here is the next section for all those who care :cool: Quote:
|
Re: Fan Scripts: Script your own version of Harry Potter
hmmm..I guess no one has anything to say for that one huh :lol:
Well I just wanted to say I made an error or sorts. There's something I wanted to do earlier but I completly forgot but I'll figure out a way to work in it. I will possibly be adding the next section on tonight hopefully..just curious on what people think about the last section before I move on so come on people :p |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:12 am. |
Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Original content is Copyright © MMII - MMVIII, CoSForums.com. All Rights Reserved.
Other content (posts, images, etc) is Copyright © its respective owners.