Chamber of Secrets

Chamber of Secrets (http://www.cosforums.com/index.php)
-   Post DH References (http://www.cosforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=170)
-   -   Pottermore v.10 (http://www.cosforums.com/showthread.php?t=130213)

Hes September 15th, 2011 9:00 am

Pottermore v.10
 
Previous version: Pottermore v.9

PLEASE READ


What is on-topic:


Questions and information about, and analysis of, Pottermore itself

What is off-topic:
  • general squeeing about Pottermore and other posts which lack substance
  • whether you have registered for Pottermore yet or not (e.g. "Yay! I've just got my username and it's Snape'sUnderpants666!"). Go to the Pitchside if you want to post that sort of thing. You can put your username in your signature if you want (although there have been reports of people who'd posted their username online being hacked so you may wish to leave the final digits off as a precaution).
  • how you are feeling/what you are doing at the moment (e.g. "I'm so excited! But I don't know how I'm going to stay up all night. Maybe I'll drink coffee?" Go to the Pitchside if you want to post that sort of thing
  • questions or comments about CoS (e.g. "How is posting my username offtopic?", "Why has my post count gone down?") There is an Ask the Staff thread where you can post these things, or you can owl a mod.
What will get you banned (amongst other things):
  • posting illegal links
  • posting your e-mail address or 'phone number or asking other members for theirs
  • repeatedly ignoring the above

Speculation

What is OK here:

Reasonable, fact-based speculation, where you try to piece together the possible ways Pottermore might work, on the basis of information about the site already in the public domain, and use hypothesis to try to fill in some of the gaps.

What is not OK here:

*Wild, unfounded speculation (e.g. if the HP actors joined Pottermore, what do you think their usernames would be?)
*General "It would be so cool if..'" wish lists
*Discussion that stops being about Pottermore and starts being about you (e.g. when a How Might the Pottermore Sorting System Work? discussion turns into a The Kind of Sorting System I Would Construct If It Were Up To Me discussion, it's off-topic)

Also, please respect the wishes of the Pottermore staff e.g. if you think you've worked out a way that members can rig their answers to the Pottermore sorting quiz to get the house they want, please don't share it here, as it's obvious that the Pottermore team don't want people to rig their quiz.

Please also respect the privacy of all of those connected to the HP franchise and do not spread unconfirmed rumours or speculation about who has a Pottermore account.

Fools_Gold September 15th, 2011 10:15 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
FIRST yay!

Anyways, I've temporarily given up on Pottermore, at least until my potions are sorted or duelling is back up.

Silver_Arrow77 September 15th, 2011 1:17 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Does anyone know how many students are on Pottermore now? Thanks :)

Hes September 15th, 2011 1:22 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
374,563 students.

Rave: 93,942 members
Huff: 94,048 members
Gryff: 93,548 members
Slyth: 93,025 members

LumosSempra September 15th, 2011 1:55 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hes (Post 5877753)
374,563 students.

Rave: 93,942 members
Huff: 94,048 members
Gryff: 93,548 members
Slyth: 93,025 members

I can't believe we're still only at 300-some thousand members. Why is it taking so long to invite the rest of the million? According to Pottermore Insider, as of September 8th, welcome emails were to go out daily. If the site is supposedly opening in October, we're only 2 weeks away, and over half of the early-entry people are still not allowed in. Doesn't seem fair that people were promised "early entry" if early entry meant waiting until the week before everyone else is allowed to register. :grumble:

kristen423 September 15th, 2011 3:00 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LumosSempra (Post 5877759)
I can't believe we're still only at 300-some thousand members. Why is it taking so long to invite the rest of the million? According to Pottermore Insider, as of September 8th, welcome emails were to go out daily. If the site is supposedly opening in October, we're only 2 weeks away, and over half of the early-entry people are still not allowed in. Doesn't seem fair that people were promised "early entry" if early entry meant waiting until the week before everyone else is allowed to register. :grumble:

As far as welcome emails going out daily, I believe that is happening although there are some days where smaller batches go out. We can see that the population in the Great Hall has increased a lot in the past few days, which is definitely a good sign.

True, it is only 2 weeks from October, but they did not set a specific date in October. This means that it could be the 1st but it could also be the 31st. I also must agree that it is not fair if people only get in a week before it opens. It seems that more than anything we are being used to test their servers, although they definitely have made some changes (points per potion).

hpfan101 September 15th, 2011 3:03 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LumosSempra (Post 5877759)
I can't believe we're still only at 300-some thousand members. Why is it taking so long to invite the rest of the million? According to Pottermore Insider, as of September 8th, welcome emails were to go out daily. If the site is supposedly opening in October, we're only 2 weeks away, and over half of the early-entry people are still not allowed in. Doesn't seem fair that people were promised "early entry" if early entry meant waiting until the week before everyone else is allowed to register. :grumble:

Yeah, I've noticed that too. I still have a family member waiting to get in (day 3 registration). They haven't even let half of the million in! I can't believe how lucky we all are to already be in.

I'm also concerned that dueling is STILL down. I've been in for a month now and it's been down since I've been in (with a few times being up for a few hours here or there...but I've always missed them). That seems like a LONG time for one of the only ways to gain points to be down.

ardnaxela September 15th, 2011 3:14 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LumosSempra (Post 5877759)
I can't believe we're still only at 300-some thousand members. Why is it taking so long to invite the rest of the million? According to Pottermore Insider, as of September 8th, welcome emails were to go out daily. If the site is supposedly opening in October, we're only 2 weeks away, and over half of the early-entry people are still not allowed in. Doesn't seem fair that people were promised "early entry" if early entry meant waiting until the week before everyone else is allowed to register. :grumble:

In fairness to the Pottermore team, this is beta access - not early access. Meaning that we are there to help them basically. They also said that people would gain entry to the beta any time from when the first emails went out until the opening of the site for everyone - that is, some beta registers could gain access the day before it opens to the public. They have been up front about this from the start. Similarly, we have to expect there to be glitches and outages. A part of beta access is to make sure the site runs smoothly from when it opens to the public.

In regards to the actual site:
Spoiler: show

I feel like a really bad fan, but is there anyone else out there like me who hasn't actually accessed the site that much? Don't get me wrong, I love it. I thought the information was wonderful, I loved the quizzes and the illustrations are simply beautiful. But being a single mum with a toddler I don't have the time for potions or practising spells (or the patience) so now I'm really just hanging out until the release of CoS. I have been on again a couple of times just to check out the illustrations and have another read through the stuff.

However, I am worried about how the site will achieve it's objective of gaining new fanbases for the series. I imagine - now this of course is my opinion and I am sure many people will disagree - that the site will become boring for anyone other than diehard fans, and non-diehards who sign up come October will only have a quick browse and will have forgotten about it by the time the rest of the series is released.

I don't want people to take this post the wrong way and think I am disappointed in the site - because I am certainly not. I had figured from the start what the site would entail and knew that once I had got through the new information that I probably wouldn't spend hours on end there because the games don't interest me (which is clearly not the case with a lot of people :)) However, I am more wondering how successful the site will be with it's objective of reeling in new fans

kristen423 September 15th, 2011 3:20 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ardnaxela (Post 5877784)

In regards to the actual site:
Spoiler: show

I feel like a really bad fan, but is there anyone else out there like me who hasn't actually accessed the site that much? Don't get me wrong, I love it. I thought the information was wonderful, I loved the quizzes and the illustrations are simply beautiful. But being a single mum with a toddler I don't have the time for potions or practising spells (or the patience) so now I'm really just hanging out until the release of CoS. I have been on again a couple of times just to check out the illustrations and have another read through the stuff.

However, I am worried about how the site will achieve it's objective of gaining new fanbases for the series. I imagine - now this of course is my opinion and I am sure many people will disagree - that the site will become boring for anyone other than diehard fans, and non-diehards who sign up come October will only have a quick browse and will have forgotten about it by the time the rest of the series is released.

I don't want people to take this post the wrong way and think I am disappointed in the site - because I am certainly not. I had figured from the start what the site would entail and knew that once I had got through the new information that I probably wouldn't spend hours on end there because the games don't interest me (which is clearly not the case with a lot of people :)) However, I am more wondering how successful the site will be with it's objective of reeling in new fans

You make a good point.

Spoiler: show
Unless they add more to the site, specifically things to keep us busy between books, it is very likely that people are going to stick around. And after DH is released, what's to stop even a bunch of diehards from leaving. Long story short, they need more for us to do. I don't brew potions as often as I could but when I do I have to plan it out, because of the long brewing time. I would like to be able to do stuff on Pottermore without having to plan things in the real world around it (although Potions make a great short break from homework).

LumosSempra September 15th, 2011 3:21 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ardnaxela (Post 5877784)
In fairness to the Pottermore team, this is beta access - not early access.

If I recall correctly, the whole thing was being advertised as "early entry" from the start. But that's just me being nitpicky. They probably were just trying to hype it up as much as possible.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ardnaxela (Post 5877784)
In regards to the actual site:
Spoiler: show

I feel like a really bad fan, but is there anyone else out there like me who hasn't actually accessed the site that much? Don't get me wrong, I love it. I thought the information was wonderful, I loved the quizzes and the illustrations are simply beautiful. But being a single mum with a toddler I don't have the time for potions or practising spells (or the patience) so now I'm really just hanging out until the release of CoS. I have been on again a couple of times just to check out the illustrations and have another read through the stuff.

However, I am worried about how the site will achieve it's objective of gaining new fanbases for the series. I imagine - now this of course is my opinion and I am sure many people will disagree - that the site will become boring for anyone other than diehard fans, and non-diehards who sign up come October will only have a quick browse and will have forgotten about it by the time the rest of the series is released.

I don't want people to take this post the wrong way and think I am disappointed in the site - because I am certainly not. I had figured from the start what the site would entail and knew that once I had got through the new information that I probably wouldn't spend hours on end there because the games don't interest me (which is clearly not the case with a lot of people :)) However, I am more wondering how successful the site will be with it's objective of reeling in new fans

Spoiler: show
I completely agree, I feel exactly the same way. I was completely obsessed with it when I first got in, but once I got through the first book, I sort of lost interest. I don't really have time to log on and brew a potion for over an hour, so I haven't tried that part yet (also, if I end up planning my life around potion-brewing, all my friends will think me a total loser. Haha). And seeing as dueling is down, I haven't had a chance to try that either. So I'm fearful that once I get through all of the new material for the series, I'll no longer want to be involved as much in the website. And I consider myself a pretty die-hard fan, so I don't know how much interest the site is going to be able to maintain once they get through the series, unless they find other ways to keep everyone involved.

HallowSword210 September 15th, 2011 3:29 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hes (Post 5877753)
374,563 students.

Rave: 93,942 members
Huff: 94,048 members
Gryff: 93,548 members
Slyth: 93,025 members

Does anyone else suspect the sorting to be random? These numbers are just way too convenient. Sorry if this has already been discussed in a previous Pottermore thread.

Daggerstone September 15th, 2011 3:41 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
I've been thinking...

Spoiler: show
What if, at some point in undefined future when more books are added, we wish to re-live the whole experience? Will there be a "reset account" option, or will we be forced to delete the old and make a new one?


I actually enjoy the Potions game, but even I'm getting bored doing the same thing over and over again. And even once the dueling is up.... there's only so many times you can cast Petrificus Totalus before it becomes mind-numbingly boring. :lol:

CharmedMom September 15th, 2011 3:41 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kristen423 (Post 5877789)
You make a good point.

Spoiler: show
Unless they add more to the site, specifically things to keep us busy between books, it is very likely that people are going to stick around. And after DH is released, what's to stop even a bunch of diehards from leaving. Long story short, they need more for us to do. I don't brew potions as often as I could but when I do I have to plan it out, because of the long brewing time. I would like to be able to do stuff on Pottermore without having to plan things in the real world around it (although Potions make a great short break from homework).

I agree with you to some extent. From my perspective, it is exactly what they advertised. But, I do hope they grow from here.

Spoiler: show
I do agree that there is little to do once you finish the book. I attempted potions frequently. They kept failing because of glitches... which I accepted due to this being beta testing. Now I do them when I feel like it. I do want to try dueling if they get it back. But, this won't be enough to bring me back indefinitely. They will probably bring the next books around faster than expected. Maybe these will add additional things to do. I think it is currently at a great starting point.

TheScribbler September 15th, 2011 3:46 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LumosSempra (Post 5877759)
I can't believe we're still only at 300-some thousand members. Why is it taking so long to invite the rest of the million? According to Pottermore Insider, as of September 8th, welcome emails were to go out daily. If the site is supposedly opening in October, we're only 2 weeks away, and over half of the early-entry people are still not allowed in. Doesn't seem fair that people were promised "early entry" if early entry meant waiting until the week before everyone else is allowed to register. :grumble:

I agree that it's weird how few people have gotten in. I expected at least 60% of those that registered would've gotten the email by now; but then again, there might be new glitches or bugs that they had to smooth out, hence the delay.
Plus, I always got the impression that when they said October, they meant October 31st. It makes sense in terms of the books and everything, and it kind of answers the question of 'why are there so few students?'.

CharmedMom September 15th, 2011 3:48 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by HallowSword210 (Post 5877793)
Does anyone else suspect the sorting to be random? These numbers are just way too convenient. Sorry if this has already been discussed in a previous Pottermore thread.

I watched my 2 daughters' answers during their sorting. They did have a similar flow to them and they both went to Slytherin. (My youngest tried to go "back" to redo it but I convinced her Slytherins are cool and not all evil!) They were done about 30 minutes apart, I think. I got entry first about a week ago and was sorted into Ravenclaw, which is also my CoS house. But who knows. The numbers do seem to be rather even!

SadiraSnape September 15th, 2011 3:50 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Sorting:

Spoiler: show
I don't think it's totally random, because there are consistently much fewer members of Slytherin than the other three houses. 500 more in Gryffindor, 900 more in Ravenclaw, and 1000 more in Hufflepuff. That's 2500 more (roughly) people distributed over the other 3 houses than Slytherin. If it were random, I'd expect less variation than that.


The site:

Spoiler: show
I'm really hoping they develop more activities, or put new stuff in the "moments" for you to find and collect -- right now all I'm doing is Potions (which I do love!), but the lengthy brewing times are a bit off-putting. Perhaps if duelling was up, but then I'm not much of a competitor that way, so I don't know if I'd bother with it. But yeah, they do need to amp it up some if they want people to keep coming after going through the chapters the first time.


Usernames:

Spoiler: show
SnapesUnderpants666? Really? :rotfl: :eeep:

BrianTung September 15th, 2011 4:04 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ardnaxela (Post 5877784)
In regards to the actual site:
Spoiler: show

However, I am worried about how the site will achieve it's objective of gaining new fanbases for the series. I imagine - now this of course is my opinion and I am sure many people will disagree - that the site will become boring for anyone other than diehard fans, and non-diehards who sign up come October will only have a quick browse and will have forgotten about it by the time the rest of the series is released.

I'm sorry, was that the site's objective? I think it might happen, especially as Pottermore advances through the following books, but I thought it was primarily just a way for Rowling to give back to her fans--meaning, her existing fans, principally.

The site, as it currently is, can only be sufficient to grab a foothold for future involvement. I like it quite a bit, but I'm a bit of a "redoer"--I rewatch movies, I reread books, and I replay games--and I'm probably not the best person to evaluate it on a subjective level. But even someone like me recognizes that it simply won't sustain most people's attention for very long in its present state. Dueling will help...but probably not for months and months.

An improved commenting system would help. Any one of the following enhancements would make it usable:
  1. Threaded comments
  2. Vastly improved moderation (seconds instead of days)
  3. Ability to search for @names or #hashtags
  4. Appearance of your own actions or comments in any restriction to "Friends"
  5. Personal (but public, not private) comment space

There are probably other measures that would help, but that's a start.

It would also help if they would let our drawings show up. It's weird, since they said, in one of the Insider posts, that users could submit artwork. Meaning it wasn't a feature they were working on, or were considering scrapping altogether. I mean, frankly, it's a bit weird. No wonder some folks think it's limiting.

Quote:

Originally Posted by SadiraSnape (Post 5877804)
Sorting:

Spoiler: show
I don't think it's totally random, because there are consistently much fewer members of Slytherin than the other three houses. 500 more in Gryffindor, 900 more in Ravenclaw, and 1000 more in Hufflepuff. That's 2500 more (roughly) people distributed over the other 3 houses than Slytherin. If it were random, I'd expect less variation than that.

"Random" needn't mean "uniformly distributed." Something that assigns 22 percent to Slytherin, say, and 26 percent to the other three houses, is still random if it assigns people to houses without regard to how they answered the questions. However, I don't think it is random in that sense, either, despite a few odd Sortings.

threecats September 15th, 2011 4:34 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianTung (Post 5877808)
... It would also help if they would let our drawings show up. It's weird, since they said, in one of the Insider posts, that users could submit artwork. Meaning it wasn't a feature they were working on, or were considering scrapping altogether. I mean, frankly, it's a bit weird. No wonder some folks think it's limiting. ...

I have seen some artwork that was uploaded by users. Well, at least I assumed they were regular users.

Spoiler: show
There are portraits for Ginny, Percy, Draco, the Bloody Baron and Professors Flitwick and Quirrell in their respective character pages. They also show up on the overview, if you add them to your favorites.

WildFloo162 September 15th, 2011 5:34 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Gosh darnit. Just waited a million hours for a potion to brew in the first step to once again have Pottermore not register my stirring motions, thus wasting my time. I really think I'm done until the site is open for all which will hopefully mean it works. I'm beyond annoyed. I get that it's a beta, and there will be bugs, but how long has Dueling been down? How long has potions been messed up for people? I mean come on. I stirred backwards as the time was ticking down, just to see if that would register. Yup it sure would. SO you'll register the wrong motion but not the right one? Ugh.

MerryLore September 15th, 2011 5:39 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by threecats (Post 5877821)

Spoiler: show
There are portraits for Ginny, Percy, Draco, the Bloody Baron and Professors Flitwick and Quirrell in their respective character pages. They also show up on the overview, if you add them to your favorites.

Spoiler: show
There previously had been drawings for Dumbledore and Snape as well, but they've all be removed. No clue why.


Quote:

Originally Posted by SadiraSnape (Post 5877804)
Sorting:

Spoiler: show
I don't think it's totally random, because there are consistently much fewer members of Slytherin than the other three houses. 500 more in Gryffindor, 900 more in Ravenclaw, and 1000 more in Hufflepuff. That's 2500 more (roughly) people distributed over the other 3 houses than Slytherin. If it were random, I'd expect less variation than that.

Spoiler: show
If it were random, I'd be a Gryffindor, you'd be a Hufflepuff......etc.....


Quote:

Originally Posted by WildFloo162 (Post 5877833)
Gosh darnit. Just waited a million hours for a potion to brew in the first step to once again have Pottermore not register my stirring motions, thus wasting my time.

Maybe this will help:

Spoiler: show
Start where the stir stick is, but use your mouse to follow the rim of the cauldron. The rim is a circle. Ignore the stick - it only goes backwards and forwards.

WildFloo162 September 15th, 2011 5:45 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
oh no i can stir, it's only the higher pointed potions that wont register the stirring motion, and it's only been happening for the last few days. i didn't have a problem when I first got on the site, it's actually been since they overhauled the points system

UnicornDust September 15th, 2011 5:48 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WildFloo162 (Post 5877838)
oh no i can stir, it's only the higher pointed potions that wont register the stirring motion, and it's only been happening for the last few days. i didn't have a problem when I first got on the site, it's actually been since they overhauled the points system

That's so weird and frustrating. I don't blame you for not wanting to put yourself through that any more.

threecats September 15th, 2011 5:53 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WildFloo162 (Post 5877838)
oh no i can stir, it's only the higher pointed potions that wont register the stirring motion, and it's only been happening for the last few days. i didn't have a problem when I first got on the site, it's actually been since they overhauled the points system

Have you rebooted your computer lately? Flash is a memory hog and can get really slow over time.

Lisl_Loveheart September 15th, 2011 6:27 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
On the subject of how many studets are in already I must say, if the site is this slow and glitchy with this many people on, I can't imagine they'll be ready for 2 or 3 times this number anytime soon. I think maybe Rowling underestimated the inicial financial investiment to run such a MAJOR site. I know nothing about technology, but I think they need better hardware, better software and more people (which all cost a lot of money). Let's hope the site does get boring for some after a while, so that those who wish to enjoy it more intensily can do so with free access.

On the subject of the sorting: there are people interested in learning if it is "random" or if the questions / answers can really capture your personality. I can say that my sorting was true and if you are interested in this, please look for the people dicussing this subject on tumblr. Maybe you can help them find the truth.

On the matter of brewing: I have a couple of tips (some heard on Pottermore)
Spoiler: show
- leave your potion open on a tab while it brews, the chance of you losing it is smaller this way
- hold bottles by its neck (or top most part), this helps you control quantities and avoid spills
- make a physical book of potions and write down your recipes, this saves your time
- if the stirring isn't working, maybe you are stirring in the wrong direction (it happened to me)
Happy brewing!

cybobbie September 15th, 2011 7:32 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianTung
Spoiler: show

Another possible recommendation is the Wideye. It has a number of things going for it. One is that two of the ingredients regenerate in the first layer of Hagrid's House, and the third ingredient is just two Galleons for 36 measures. That works out to about a Sickle per successful potion. Not bad for a nine-point potion.

Another is that it doesn't have any weird timing things, like having to add an ingredient while the cauldron is still on heat (whatever that means, exactly).

And a third thing is that it's fairly heavily front-loaded. The second page is dirt simple: Add two twigs of wolfsbane, and stir three times counter-clockwise (anti-clockwise for you UK-ers). That's it. The advantage of that is that it's extremely unlikely that you'll spend 95 minutes brewing this thing, only to foul it up in the second half.

Thank you BrianTung, I will try the Wideye next. Today I have tons of work but tomorrow I will do it ;)

silverowl September 15th, 2011 8:06 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cybobbie (Post 5877946)
Thank you BrianTung, I will try the Wideye next. Today I have tons of work but tomorrow I will do it ;)


That one is my favorite.

Spoiler: show
Just make sure you use the on-screen counter for all the amounts required. Sometimes it is flakey about registering what you have done. Also, remember if you put too much in, or are running out of time...refresh. It will let you start over without blowing up a cauldron.

leah49 September 15th, 2011 8:22 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Though refreshing sucks when you've already gone through the 80 or so minute waiting...

Hes September 15th, 2011 9:45 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Reminder

please respect the wishes of the Pottermore staff e.g. if you think you've worked out a way that members can rig their answers to the Pottermore sorting quiz to get the house they want, please don't share it here, as it's obvious that the Pottermore team don't want people to rig their quiz. This includes hinting at websites/spreadsheets were people collect questions/answers to the sorting.

ignisia September 16th, 2011 12:18 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Spoiler: show
I remember when the HBP game for the Wii came out, and every time you would brew a new potion, they'd give you some sort of coaching beforehand on what the new techniques in this potion were and how to use them. Your ingredients and procedure were also to some degree labeled right in front of your eyes. I blew up a few potions from time to time, but that was usually because I wasn't fast enough or made some error, not because I had no clue what to do next. And when I did mess up, the game let me know and there was often some way to salvage it. You also had the Potions club in the greenhouse, where you could practice everything you'd brewed. I would like some of this to appear in the Pottermore potions section.

I especially think there really should be more practice potions available. I was only able to brew one potion for practice, so I was only able to figure out how to use and identify about four ingredients in the practice session (yes, there are pictures in the book, but they're tiny and it took actual looking to find them when I was under the time limit). The dried billywig stings, apart from having the most counter-intuitive name ever (how can something dry be liquid?) was a pain to effectively use. This wouldn't be such a problem if there'd been a way I could identify and use the ingredient without risking points each time I tried to use it. After a while, I could probably figure out a way, but it isn't worth -5 points for each attempt. I do know about reloading, but I think the game should be possible without resorting to that. Since there is one potion available for practice, I don't see why others can't be.

There's also apparently some force-field preventing you from passing anything in front of your cauldron. Clearly some meddling prankster with a thorough knowledge of warding spells is behind this, because air normally doesn't work that way. :rotfl:

UnicornDust September 16th, 2011 2:17 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ignisia (Post 5878254)
Spoiler: show
I remember when the HBP game for the Wii came out, and every time you would brew a new potion, they'd give you some sort of coaching beforehand on what the new techniques in this potion were and how to use them. Your ingredients and procedure were also to some degree labeled right in front of your eyes. I blew up a few potions from time to time, but that was usually because I wasn't fast enough or made some error, not because I had no clue what to do next. And when I did mess up, the game let me know and there was often some way to salvage it. You also had the Potions club in the greenhouse, where you could practice everything you'd brewed. I would like some of this to appear in the Pottermore potions section.

I especially think there really should be more practice potions available. I was only able to brew one potion for practice, so I was only able to figure out how to use and identify about four ingredients in the practice session (yes, there are pictures in the book, but they're tiny and it took actual looking to find them when I was under the time limit). The dried billywig stings, apart from having the most counter-intuitive name ever (how can something dry be liquid?) was a pain to effectively use. This wouldn't be such a problem if there'd been a way I could identify and use the ingredient without risking points each time I tried to use it. After a while, I could probably figure out a way, but it isn't worth -5 points for each attempt. I do know about reloading, but I think the game should be possible without resorting to that. Since there is one potion available for practice, I don't see why others can't be.

There's also apparently some force-field preventing you from passing anything in front of your cauldron. Clearly some meddling prankster with a thorough knowledge of warding spells is behind this, because air normally doesn't work that way. :rotfl:

You make some excellent points.
Spoiler: show
I would very much like to be able to practice handling the ingredients before trying a potion for the first time. Those bottles are tricky and there are differences between them. And I would like to be able to have the book open while working to be able to identify ingredients, etc. It takes too much time switching back to the book.

LumosSempra September 16th, 2011 2:43 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Spoiler: show
Well I just spent practically my entire night brewing the Cure for Boils. I finally did it, only to receive 3 lousy house points. I still don't understand how some people are up to the thousands in points! Do they spend all day long endlessly brewing potions? Don't they run out of galleons after a while? Or is 400 galleons enough to brew hundreds of potions?

Also, does the type of cauldron you use make a difference? I bought a copper cauldron because it says it brews potions faster, but my potion still took 80 minutes to brew. Would it have taken longer on a pewter cauldron?

hpfan101 September 16th, 2011 2:46 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Anyone else having trouble with the Sleeping Draught? Every time I try to brew that particular potion, I wait my time and it takes me back to page 1. So I waste 90 minutes every time! I'm not having a problem with any other potion, only that one.

ignisia September 16th, 2011 2:49 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LumosSempra (Post 5878354)
Spoiler: show
Well I just spent practically my entire night brewing the Cure for Boils. I finally did it, only to receive 3 lousy house points. I still don't understand how some people are up to the thousands in points! Do they spend all day long endlessly brewing potions? Don't they run out of galleons after a while? Or is 400 galleons enough to brew hundreds of potions?

Also, does the type of cauldron you use make a difference? I bought a copper cauldron because it says it brews potions faster, but my potion still took 80 minutes to brew. Would it have taken longer on a pewter cauldron?

Spoiler: show
Cure for Boils is the only one I've managed so far. :lol: I use Pewter because I'm cheap, and it's still 80 minutes on that one. Interesting that it isn't faster on other cauldrons. Definitely going to keep my galleons, then.

ccollinsmith September 16th, 2011 2:54 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LumosSempra (Post 5878354)
Spoiler: show
Well I just spent practically my entire night brewing the Cure for Boils. I finally did it, only to receive 3 lousy house points. I still don't understand how some people are up to the thousands in points! Do they spend all day long endlessly brewing potions? Don't they run out of galleons after a while? Or is 400 galleons enough to brew hundreds of potions?

Also, does the type of cauldron you use make a difference? I bought a copper cauldron because it says it brews potions faster, but my potion still took 80 minutes to brew. Would it have taken longer on a pewter cauldron?

Spoiler: show
Once upon a time - until a couple of days before I got into Pottermore - there was dueling. That's how people racked up all those points.

It takes shorter teams to heat the brass and copper cauldrons. It takes the same time to brew.


UnicornDust September 16th, 2011 3:03 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ccollinsmith (Post 5878363)
Spoiler: show
Once upon a time - until a couple of days before I got into Pottermore - there was dueling. That's how people racked up all those points.

It takes shorter teams to heat the brass and copper cauldrons. It takes the same time to brew.


Spoiler: show
I wonder if it will be shorter brewing times with the more expensive cauldrons after the site opens in October. Definitely not worth the money now.

ardnaxela September 16th, 2011 3:09 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianTung (Post 5877808)
I'm sorry, was that the site's objective? I think it might happen, especially as Pottermore advances through the following books, but I thought it was primarily just a way for Rowling to give back to her fans--meaning, her existing fans, principally.

The site, as it currently is, can only be sufficient to grab a foothold for future involvement. I like it quite a bit, but I'm a bit of a "redoer"--I rewatch movies, I reread books, and I replay games--and I'm probably not the best person to evaluate it on a subjective level. But even someone like me recognizes that it simply won't sustain most people's attention for very long in its present state. Dueling will help...but probably not for months and months.

Sorry I didn't intend for my post to imply that I thought that grabbing new fans was the sites only objective - because it's certainly not. It's not even the sites main objective - which is to my knowledge, as you said, to be a 'give-back' to current fans. However in the information that was released by JK and the Pottermore team there was definite mention of it being a tool to bring in new fans, and also to introduce HP to a new generation. (I will go hunt down the quotes now.)

ccollinsmith September 16th, 2011 3:17 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UnicornDust (Post 5878368)
Spoiler: show
I wonder if it will be shorter brewing times with the more expensive cauldrons after the site opens in October. Definitely not worth the money now.

Spoiler: show
That's a possiblity. The Pottermore Insider said they'd be tweaking brewing times. So maybe the tweaks will come with the more expensive cauldrons.

But yeah... not worth the money now. Plus, I promptly blew up a copper cauldron on Cure for Boils because it heated too fast even on medium. :lol: I probably wouldn't blow it up now on that potion because I know a few more heating tricks, but I'm still a bit skittish over anything but my pewter cauldron at the moment.

UnicornDust September 16th, 2011 3:17 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hpfan101 (Post 5878355)
Anyone else having trouble with the Sleeping Draught? Every time I try to brew that particular potion, I wait my time and it takes me back to page 1. So I waste 90 minutes every time! I'm not having a problem with any other potion, only that one.

Spoiler: show
I have had that frustration with sleeping draught, but I have also been able to complete it sometimes. For a while I thought I was in the dreaded potions loop, but maybe it was just because I was doing sleeping draught (or trying to) so much.

hpfan101 September 16th, 2011 3:27 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UnicornDust (Post 5878375)
Spoiler: show
I have had that frustration with sleeping draught, but I have also been able to complete it sometimes. For a while I thought I was in the dreaded potions loop, but maybe it was just because I was doing sleeping draught (or trying to) so much.

I thought that too, but I've been able to just wave my wand, "fail" the potion :grumble: and then start a new one that's NOT the sleeping draught. It's annoying because that one is worth the most points and I can't do it and I'm beginning to think that after three tries, I'm just going to stay away from that one and focus on the ones that work.

blueroses September 16th, 2011 3:30 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
I'm actually a little dissapointed with Pottermore. I think the anticipation of getting in was better than the site itself. After the book was finished I haven't been on much. I kept screwing up the practice potion. Apparently you have to wait in between dropping the snake fangs in (so the little counter goes away) which takes up more time and makes me run out of time. I think they tried to make is SO child-friendly that it is..boring.

MarauderIce39 September 16th, 2011 4:26 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hpfan101 (Post 5878355)
Anyone else having trouble with the Sleeping Draught? Every time I try to brew that particular potion, I wait my time and it takes me back to page 1. So I waste 90 minutes every time! I'm not having a problem with any other potion, only that one.

I was - and I suppose still could be - having problems with Sleeping Draught, but I've brewed several successfully now, so I am wondering if my solution has resolved my issues and is allowing me to avoid the step 1 loop.

Basically, I stopped trying to brew only Sleeping Draught. Now I alternate between S/D and one of the 9-pointers (Wide Eye or Forgetfullness). That seems to keep each from exhibiting a glitch and failing.

EDIT: Spoke to soon! Just had another Sleeping Draught fail by going back to Step 1 after brewing. Grr! I give up for tonight! (Hmm... wonder if the fact that I started it technically yesterday - before midnight - and it had to brew until sometime after midnight, if that has anything to do with it. I don't know!)

SadiraSnape September 16th, 2011 4:32 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
On Brewing...

Spoiler: show
I used the document someone posted in the previous Pottermore that had all the potions on it, then split it up into a text doc for each potion. That way I can have the instructions available and not have to worry about Flash choking or something -- I just pull up my little text file.

It's also helpful because I can go over the instructions right before the time ends, so I know I need to immediately grab the horklump juice etc. etc.

Aaaaand I blew up another copper cauldron today. Herbicide Potion. I discovered that, even if you brew everything right, if you've been sloppy and spilled the Flobberworm Mucus and didn't pick it up, you're going to fail. So. Be neat!

Arya_ September 16th, 2011 10:43 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianTung (Post 5877808)

It would also help if they would let our drawings show up. It's weird, since they said, in one of the Insider posts, that users could submit artwork. Meaning it wasn't a feature they were working on, or were considering scrapping altogether. I mean, frankly, it's a bit weird. No wonder some folks think it's limiting.

Yes this is very annoying! I posted an artwork as soon as I had joined on the 26th/27th of August, the artwork still hasn't been approved yet.

I mean are they only expecting sketched and stick figures to be uploaded? what about the more experienced professional artists? Will their artwork be rejected because it might clash with copyright etc etc? why is it taking so long????

Miss_Gaunt September 16th, 2011 2:18 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
The Insider's been updated:

Pottermore InsiderAccessing Pottermore
UPDATED ON FRIDAY 16 SEPTEMBER

Over the past 24 hours, we've slowed down the rate at which Welcome emails are being sent out due to some work that's being carried out on the site.

We want to wait until this work has finished and make sure that everything is working properly before we speed up again.

We'll keep you updated using this post.


Bad news for everyone still waiting for their email but hopefully this means they're fixing potion glitches and will bring duelling back up soon. :D

LumosSempra September 16th, 2011 2:20 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Miss_Gaunt (Post 5878563)
Bad news for everyone still waiting for their email but hopefully this means they're fixing potion glitches and will bring duelling back up soon. :D

Sounds like Halloween will have come and gone before they finally open the site officially! :grumble:

threecats September 16th, 2011 2:26 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
And it's down for maintenance already.:upset: If it's anything like last weekend, there will be quite a few outages over the next day or two, so I'm not going to start any more potions until they're done. It's too frustrating to have a potion spoiled because they shut the system down right when it's ready for finishing up.

hpfan101 September 16th, 2011 3:08 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by threecats (Post 5878569)
And it's down for maintenance already.:upset: If it's anything like last weekend, there will be quite a few outages over the next day or two, so I'm not going to start any more potions until they're done. It's too frustrating to have a potion spoiled because they shut the system down right when it's ready for finishing up.

Grrr...why do they insist on working on the site when it's the weekend? That's when I'm off work!

MarauderIce, I'm just going to stay away from Sleeping Draught for now...although maybe they'll have fixed it once the site comes back up, which means I will prob be wasting another 100 minutes waiting for a possible "Fail."

Silver_Arrow77 September 16th, 2011 3:40 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
How many students are on Pottermore?

Hes September 16th, 2011 3:43 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Silver_Arrow77 (Post 5878611)
How many students are on Pottermore?

This thread is meant for constructive posting. Asking every day about how many people are in Pottermore isn't constructive posting but we consider this post count boosting. If you want to chat or ask this daily question do so in the Pitchside.

threecats September 16th, 2011 3:46 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hpfan101 (Post 5878596)
Grrr...why do they insist on working on the site when it's the weekend? That's when I'm off work! ...

It's probably just habit. For most computer systems, late nights and weekends are the only times we are allowed to do any kind of maintenance, and for business critical systems we're lucky to get a couple of hours between 1 am and 3 am on a Saturday night once every 3 months.;)

Over the last week I have observed that a lot of outages, but not all, occur after 5 pm and often after 7 pm EDT (10 pm / midnight in Britain). So it looks to me like they are trying to affect at least the Europeans at little as possible, and other time zones are just SOL. That's what happens with global systems.

TabbyCat1 September 16th, 2011 3:57 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LumosSempra (Post 5877759)
I can't believe we're still only at 300-some thousand members. Why is it taking so long to invite the rest of the million? According to Pottermore Insider, as of September 8th, welcome emails were to go out daily. If the site is supposedly opening in October, we're only 2 weeks away, and over half of the early-entry people are still not allowed in. Doesn't seem fair that people were promised "early entry" if early entry meant waiting until the week before everyone else is allowed to register. :grumble:

Two weeks away? Gosh, that's not very long! I haven't even completed Sorcerer's Stone yet. I don't have enough time.

I sure hope they let everyone in...

Is the website still down?

IronBellyDragon September 16th, 2011 4:08 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TabbyCat1 (Post 5878625)
Two weeks away? Gosh, that's not very long! I haven't even completed Sorcerer's Stone yet. I don't have enough time.

I sure hope they let everyone in...

Is the website still down?

The statement "opening in October" doesn't necessarily mean opening on the 1st of October. When you think that Harry's parents were killed on Halloween, it would make a lots of sense to open on the 31st. But even that is not certain.

And the site is down for "routine updates."

silverowl September 16th, 2011 4:52 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by threecats (Post 5878617)
It's probably just habit. For most computer systems, late nights and weekends are the only times we are allowed to do any kind of maintenance, and for business critical systems we're lucky to get a couple of hours between 1 am and 3 am on a Saturday night once every 3 months.;)

Over the last week I have observed that a lot of outages, but not all, occur after 5 pm and often after 7 pm EDT (10 pm / midnight in Britain). So it looks to me like they are trying to affect at least the Europeans at little as possible, and other time zones are just SOL. That's what happens with global systems.

Perhaps they have figured out that their heaviest use is on the weekend...and that is why they are down for maint. on Friday during European and US working hours.

Silver_Arrow77 September 16th, 2011 5:43 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hes (Post 5878612)
This thread is meant for constructive posting. Asking every day about how many people are in Pottermore isn't constructive posting but we consider this post count boosting. If you want to chat or ask this daily question do so in the Pitchside.

I'm sorry about that. I just want to know how many people are on Pottermore to be able to estimate when I will finally get my Welcome e-mail. I think it's really unfair that Pottermore is letting in so many people, not just me, so late. After all, I registered early on Day 4, so I think I should have gotten my e-mail by now if the system were fairer. Sending out e-mails completely on a first come first serve basis would have been so much better.:sigh:

Hufflepuffchill September 16th, 2011 5:46 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
I am disappointed they slowed down the welcome emails. I must be so close. I created one for my friend early in day 4 and he got his on tuesday. I did mine really early in day 5 and have yet to get mine. I would imagine I have to be in the next big batch.

StormBronze September 16th, 2011 6:46 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Silver_Arrow77 (Post 5878695)
I'm sorry about that. I just want to know how many people are on Pottermore to be able to estimate when I will finally get my Welcome e-mail. I think it's really unfair that Pottermore is letting in so many people, not just me, so late. After all, I registered early on Day 4, so I think I should have gotten my e-mail by now if the system were fairer. Sending out e-mails completely on a first come first serve basis would have been so much better.:sigh:

Sometimes we have to wait for things in life. Asking constantly how many people are in is not going to help you estimate when you are going to get in. There was life before Pottermore, there will be life after, and you'd probably be happier waiting if you found a hobby to keep you busy.

It'll be fine. At some point in the next couple weeks you'll find out what kind of wand you get and what house you'll be in, and then you can play with games that don't work right now and will hopefully work when you get in.

TabbyCat1 September 16th, 2011 7:41 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by IronBellyDragon (Post 5878632)
The statement "opening in October" doesn't necessarily mean opening on the 1st of October. When you think that Harry's parents were killed on Halloween, it would make a lots of sense to open on the 31st. But even that is not certain.

And the site is down for "routine updates."

Okay. Whatever they do, I'm sure it will work out. :) It does say in the T&C that they have the right to extend (or shorten, though I doubt they'd do that unless the cheating gets worse-it does say they have the right to terminate any/all accounts if cheating occurs somewhere) the beta testing, so maybe they'll do that.

In case you haven't read the Insider, a new update went out today which pretty much explains it all. I suggest you visit insider.pottermore.com to see it for yourself. ;)

Quote:

Spoiler: show
Accessing Pottermore
UPDATED ON FRIDAY 16 SEPTEMBER

Over the past 24 hours, we've slowed down the rate at which Welcome emails are being sent out due to some work that's being carried out on the site.

We want to wait until this work has finished and make sure that everything is working properly before we speed up again.

We'll keep you updated using this post.
Posted by Pottermore Editor at 12:00

There's the quote.

Nnylarak September 16th, 2011 8:04 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Potions question:
Spoiler: show
What's the difference between the yellow button and the red button under the cauldron? I understand that the red button heats the cauldron up faster than the yellow one, but are there specific times to use each one?

ignisia September 16th, 2011 8:14 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Spoiler: show
I've used the yellow button to slow down the heating of the cauldron. By hitting it a lot, I find I can keep the temperature level, for at least a little while.

BrianTung September 16th, 2011 8:16 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ignisia (Post 5878855)
Spoiler: show
I've used the yellow button to slow down the heating of the cauldron. By hitting it a lot, I find I can keep the temperature level, for at least a little while.

Spoiler: show

Interestingly, it depends on your machine. On my son's low-power netbook, the cauldron temperature can actually drop when using low heat. So while I use off and low heat to modulate the temperature, he has to use high and low heat to do the same.

owlycherries September 16th, 2011 8:21 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianTung (Post 5878857)
Spoiler: show

Interestingly, it depends on your machine. On my son's low-power netbook, the cauldron temperature can actually drop when using low heat. So while I use off and low heat to modulate the temperature, he has to use high and low heat to do the same.

Spoiler: show
This. When I use the orange heat, it makes the temperature drop, so generally I use red heat and off to control it. Only very occasionally will the orange heat increase my temperature.:shrug:

LumosSempra September 16th, 2011 9:28 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Silver_Arrow77 (Post 5878695)
I'm sorry about that. I just want to know how many people are on Pottermore to be able to estimate when I will finally get my Welcome e-mail. I think it's really unfair that Pottermore is letting in so many people, not just me, so late. After all, I registered early on Day 4, so I think I should have gotten my e-mail by now if the system were fairer. Sending out e-mails completely on a first come first serve basis would have been so much better.:sigh:

That's odd. I wonder if they're sending the emails out at a more random order, because I registered on day 4 as well and I got my email on Sunday. My boyfriend registered on day 5 and he has yet to get his. :hmm: Ohh well, you'll get in soon enough! Honestly, I'm barely on it anymore because there's not much else you can do after you get through the first book besides potions, and I just don't have a lot of time to do those. Plus the site's always down for maintenance, so maybe you'll get lucky and everything will be working just fine when you finally get in. Hang in there!

silverowl September 16th, 2011 9:35 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by owlycherries (Post 5878863)
Spoiler: show
This. When I use the orange heat, it makes the temperature drop, so generally I use red heat and off to control it. Only very occasionally will the orange heat increase my temperature.:shrug:

I noticed that the faster the machine the easier time I have. On the slower machines it is very easy to make mistakes.

Spoiler: show
I also noticed it is very difficult to handle the bottles on the slower machines. They swing around and are generally out of control. On the faster machine they are not nearly as troublesome to work with.

MarauderIce39 September 16th, 2011 10:26 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianTung (Post 5878857)
Spoiler: show

Interestingly, it depends on your machine. On my son's low-power netbook, the cauldron temperature can actually drop when using low heat. So while I use off and low heat to modulate the temperature, he has to use high and low heat to do the same.

Quote:

Originally Posted by owlycherries (Post 5878863)
Spoiler: show
This. When I use the orange heat, it makes the temperature drop, so generally I use red heat and off to control it. Only very occasionally will the orange heat increase my temperature.:shrug:

Spoiler: show
Wow! This is really interesting... I use off and low heat as well because high heat is just too much. I only use that when I have to get the temp to the top range of the gauge and then I back off using off and low. Low heat always increases in temp for me, so I am always turning it off and on to keep the temp within range.

UnicornDust September 16th, 2011 10:30 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MarauderIce39 (Post 5878974)
Spoiler: show
Wow! This is really interesting... I use off and low heat as well because high heat is just too much. I only use that when I have to get the temp to the top range of the gauge and then I back off using off and low. Low heat always increases in temp for me, so I am always turning it off and on to keep the temp within range.

Spoiler: show
It is exactly the same way on my laptop. That is so interesting about the machine making a difference. I think it also makes a difference if you have other processes running in the background.

BrianTung September 16th, 2011 10:33 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UnicornDust (Post 5878980)
Spoiler: show
It is exactly the same way on my laptop. That is so interesting about the machine making a difference. I think it also makes a difference if you have other processes running in the background.

Spoiler: show
If you look at the Pottermetrics subthread (search for "Pottermetrics" in "Search this thread"), my most recent post there described a short series of trials in which creating extra Flash animation load caused the cauldron to slow down its rate of heating.

UnicornDust September 16th, 2011 10:36 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianTung (Post 5878986)
Spoiler: show
If you look at the Pottermetrics subthread (search for "Pottermetrics" in "Search this thread"), my most recent post there described a short series of trials in which creating extra Flash animation load caused the cauldron to slow down its rate of heating.

Yes, I read that
Spoiler: show
and tried it. I started sometimes purposely spilling a bottle so that I could control the heat easier. Then I read somewhere that someone blew a cauldron from spilling a bottle and not picking it up, so I stopped doing that. However, I don't know if that person was correct about what made their cauldron explode.

RemusLupinFan September 17th, 2011 1:39 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Spoiler: show
Quote:

Originally Posted by UnicornDust (Post 5878988)
I started sometimes purposely spilling a bottle so that I could control the heat easier. Then I read somewhere that someone blew a cauldron from spilling a bottle and not picking it up, so I stopped doing that. However, I don't know if that person was correct about what made their cauldron explode.

I accidentally dropped one of the Valerian sprigs on the counter one time when doing the Sleeping Draught, and it failed me. It told me I put the Valerian sprigs in the wrong container. So it does look like being messy can fail you. And that happened after I'd waited the 100 minutes. :grumble:

Regarding the heating, I've been able to get by fine with using the red button to heat up quickly, and then using the orange and off buttons to modulate the temperature.

ccollinsmith September 17th, 2011 2:53 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RemusLupinFan (Post 5879118)
Spoiler: show
I accidentally dropped one of the Valerian sprigs on the counter one time when doing the Sleeping Draught, and it failed me. It told me I put the Valerian sprigs in the wrong container. So it does look like being messy can fail you. And that happened after I'd waited the 100 minutes. :grumble:

Spoiler: show
Interesting. I dropped an entire bottle of mistletoe berries on the counter once after I'd gotten the proper measurement inside the cauldron, but I completed the potion and got the points. And when I say dropped, I mean, that the bottle was lying on its side while I finished the potion. :lol:

ArryGrotter September 17th, 2011 3:10 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RemusLupinFan (Post 5879118)
Spoiler: show
I accidentally dropped one of the Valerian sprigs on the counter one time when doing the Sleeping Draught, and it failed me. It told me I put the Valerian sprigs in the wrong container. So it does look like being messy can fail you. And that happened after I'd waited the 100 minutes. :grumble:

Regarding the heating, I've been able to get by fine with using the red button to heat up quickly, and then using the orange and off buttons to modulate the temperature.

This same thing happened to me, so I've been careful and it hasn't happened since :)

SadiraSnape September 17th, 2011 3:52 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Potions...

Spoiler: show
I was finishing up Herbicide and dropped the Flobberworm mucus. I was running out of time, so instead of picking it up and setting it upright, I waved my wand, and exploded the cauldron. So apparently Neatness Counts.

hpfan101 September 17th, 2011 5:27 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
That's so odd: I've actually let bottles remain on their side and completed the potion with no problem. I've "failed" potions because I went through the steps too quickly and although even the counter registered the correct number of ingredients, I guess I didn't wait long enough for them to "take."

Spoiler: show
This seems to happen the most with the Sleeping Draught and lavender. I find that I have to wait a few seconds between dropping the lavender into the mortar and then wait again before I add the standard ingredient. I then have to grind the mixture well past the minimum line on the mortar or else it tells me I've added lavender to the wrong place :shrug:

Daggerstone September 17th, 2011 11:25 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by blueroses (Post 5878385)
I think they tried to make is SO child-friendly that it is..boring.

Spoiler: show
Personally, I think they've miscalculated a bit when it comes to the average age of Pottermore users. There definitely has to be a way to conduct a proper conversation if adults are to be kept entertained - |your comment will appear soon" simply doesn't cut it. :lol:

Moderating input content is fine, but if it's taking too long there's no point in commenting (unless all they want is random "Wow! Pmore is SO cool!" quotes for the press releases :p) - and it WOULD save them the effort of making more interactive content to keep the clicks going.

Unlocking additional shops in Diagon Alley would help, too. If I enter the Apothecary once more, they'll roll out the red carpet for me. :grumble:


Quote:

Originally Posted by hpfan101 (Post 5879307)
I've actually let bottles remain on their side and completed the potion with no problem.

Same here, though it hasn't happened recently.... perhaps it's a recent addition? :hmm:

owlycherries September 17th, 2011 12:47 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Spoiler: show
This is driving me mad. I have been trying to make the Sleeping Draught for the last few days and it NEVER works now!

I have just attempted one with the utmost care and precision. I made sure I ddin't spill ANYTHING, I waited a few seconds after adding each ingredient to make sure it registered even after the little number came up saying it had, I put every ingredient in the right place, I did everything PERFECTLY!
But still I get green fumes and "sorry, this potion was not brewed correctly because you put the standard_ingredient in the wrong container."
Give me strength! I did not! I made sure I did everything perfectly. :upset:

I feel like giving up with potions. Even when I do it right it's apparently wrong. And the brewing times are ridiculous, I don't have time to wait around for an hour and a half.

UnicornDust September 17th, 2011 3:21 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by owlycherries (Post 5879390)
Spoiler: show
This is driving me mad. I have been trying to make the Sleeping Draught for the last few days and it NEVER works now!

I have just attempted one with the utmost care and precision. I made sure I ddin't spill ANYTHING, I waited a few seconds after adding each ingredient to make sure it registered even after the little number came up saying it had, I put every ingredient in the right place, I did everything PERFECTLY!
But still I get green fumes and "sorry, this potion was not brewed correctly because you put the standard_ingredient in the wrong container."
Give me strength! I did not! I made sure I did everything perfectly. :upset:

I feel like giving up with potions. Even when I do it right it's apparently wrong. And the brewing times are ridiculous, I don't have time to wait around for an hour and a half.

Spoiler: show
I have had the same problem as you with regard to Sleeping Draught and it saying I put something in the wrong container. I also had the problem of waiting 100 minutes only to be brought back to start over and never complete it. However, since the site came back up yesterday after being down a long time, I have made Sleeping Draught 2 times with no problems. I would recommend trying again now.

owlycherries September 17th, 2011 3:47 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UnicornDust (Post 5879458)
Spoiler: show
I have had the same problem as you with regard to Sleeping Draught and it saying I put something in the wrong container. I also had the problem of waiting 100 minutes only to be brought back to start over and never complete it. However, since the site came back up yesterday after being down a long time, I have made Sleeping Draught 2 times with no problems. I would recommend trying again now.

Spoiler: show
I'll have one more go in a minute, and i'll report back. However, something else has made me fume as well now. I had just finished waiting the 95 minutes for my herbicide, and when I did the second part I accidently added 3 of the mucus instead of two. I know, my fault this time, but it makes me mad that I get nothing for it. I just wasted 95 minutes for not even one point.
They should change it so that even though you get no points if you mess up on the first part of the potion, if you mess up the SECOND part you still get a point. If you get me.


Spoiler: show
Just tried Sleeping Draught again, and no luck. Did it perfectly, but apparently I put the lavender in the wrong container this time.

Guess I can't get those 11 points then. =[

threecats September 17th, 2011 5:05 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by owlycherries (Post 5879468)
Spoiler: show
I'll have one more go in a minute, and i'll report back. However, something else has made me fume as well now. I had just finished waiting the 95 minutes for my herbicide, and when I did the second part I accidently added 3 of the mucus instead of two. I know, my fault this time, but it makes me mad that I get nothing for it. I just wasted 95 minutes for not even one point.
They should change it so that even though you get no points if you mess up on the first part of the potion, if you mess up the SECOND part you still get a point. If you get me.


Spoiler: show
Just tried Sleeping Draught again, and no luck. Did it perfectly, but apparently I put the lavender in the wrong container this time.

Guess I can't get those 11 points then. =[

Spoiler: show
If you make a mistake like adding too much mucus, just refresh the screen, and you can start it over without a penalty.;)

hpfan101 September 17th, 2011 5:18 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Potions sure is frustrating...I'm now having problems where every potion I try takes me back to page 1 after I wait... then I have to wave the wand to "fail" the potion so I can start over. Yesterday, it was the Sleeping Draught, today it happened with the Wide-eye. I'm currently brewing Cure for Boils (grrr...ONLY 3 points)...hopefully it will work :(

UnicornDust September 17th, 2011 5:31 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Spoiler: show
Just tried Sleeping Draught again, and no luck. Did it perfectly, but apparently I put the lavender in the wrong container this time.

Guess I can't get those 11 points then. =[
[/quote]

I'm so sorry, I really thought it was fixed. Also,
Spoiler: show
I totally agree that you should get at least a point for getting past the first stage properly. It is incredibly frustrating to waste so much time waiting only to fail in the end and not get anything at all. Especially when the time has run out because the site was down.


Quote:

Originally Posted by hpfan101 (Post 5879552)
Potions sure is frustrating...I'm now having problems where every potion I try takes me back to page 1 after I wait... then I have to wave the wand to "fail" the potion so I can start over. Yesterday, it was the Sleeping Draught, today it happened with the Wide-eye. I'm currently brewing Cure for Boils (grrr...ONLY 3 points)...hopefully it will work :(

You should
Spoiler: show
owl IronBellyDragon for a recommendation for this problem.

owlycherries September 17th, 2011 5:36 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by threecats (Post 5879543)
Spoiler: show
If you make a mistake like adding too much mucus, just refresh the screen, and you can start it over without a penalty.;)

Spoiler: show
Thanks i'll try that.

I just did a Sleeping Draught again and it actually worked ... curious...

UnicornDust September 17th, 2011 5:39 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by owlycherries (Post 5879571)
Spoiler: show
Thanks i'll try that.

I just did a Sleeping Draught again and it actually worked ... curious...

Oh, that's great!

threecats September 17th, 2011 6:52 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
About ingredients in wrong container ...

Spoiler: show
I just had it happen to me when working on the sleeping draught, that it told me I had put the lavender in the wrong container. I know I did not do that, but I think I accidentally bumped one of the sprigs against the cauldron before dropping it into the mortar. Maybe that made some of it go into the cauldron. I tried again making sure to lift all ingredients properly across the cauldron, and it worked fine.

MerryLore September 17th, 2011 8:20 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by threecats (Post 5879658)
About ingredients in wrong container ...

Spoiler: show
I just had it happen to me when working on the sleeping draught, that it told me I had put the lavender in the wrong container. I know I did not do that, but I think I accidentally bumped one of the sprigs against the cauldron before dropping it into the mortar. Maybe that made some of it go into the cauldron. I tried again making sure to lift all ingredients properly across the cauldron, and it worked fine.

Potions don't seem to work for me on Saturdays. I would recommend avoiding them on the weekends.

Spoiler: show
I had the same issue with the same potion you had, tried it again, it told me to return in 95 or so minutes, and when I came back, it made me start over. I failed on purpose, to stay out of the potions loop. So I tried another potion, returned after 2 hours, and it wanted me to start over. I had to fail that one, as well. And I can brew 3 to 4 potions a day with no issues.

AurorAccio16 September 18th, 2011 2:18 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MerryLore (Post 5879740)
Potions don't seem to work for me on Saturdays. I would recommend avoiding them on the weekends.

Spoiler: show
I had the same issue with the same potion you had, tried it again, it told me to return in 95 or so minutes, and when I came back, it made me start over. I failed on purpose, to stay out of the potions loop. So I tried another potion, returned after 2 hours, and it wanted me to start over. I had to fail that one, as well. And I can brew 3 to 4 potions a day with no issues.

At first I thought: yeah sure.. but now I don't know anymore :sigh:

Spoiler: show
I was busy at the second part of the sleeping draught. Did everything as described, no glitch or whatsoever. Received the: congratulate page! Went back , only to see an owl telling me: sorry, sleeping draught failed to brew. You have not been awarded any housepoints. Come again? :hmm:


So that's it. I'm done with Potions. If the messages are going to contradict themselves it ain't no fun anymore waiting so long, when you think you've got 11 points while you receive none at all. :argh:

AccioDragon102 September 18th, 2011 7:45 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Hey, guys. How are you? Anyone having issues with potion brewing today?
Spoiler: show

I brewed one incorrectly and it destroyed my cauldron. So, I got a new one and started over. Now, whenever I try to brew it gives me the standard wait 80 minutes...0% message...But then it doesn't take. The site takes me back to the Potions page and it's not brewing. I don't know why. It shows my cauldron available to use and when I went to it I was able to brew any potion ( and if my potion was brewing it should have shown up as 2% brewing or whatever and showed my cauldron in use). What's going on?


Ahhh! I see others have having issues.lol. Should have read the thread. Although, I don't think anyone is having my issue. Any suggestions?

Annett September 18th, 2011 8:43 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Hi everyone,

finally got into Beta, only to encounter a fairly nasty problem:

Spoiler: show
I`m in Diagon Alley, buying items of the shopping list. I followed the list, that anybody could see because all but the wand is crossed through. But if I look in my trunk, I have only 5 objects and exactly 5 books. My galleons budget is exactly as it should be after byuing all thats crossed out.
I waited a couple of days, nothing has changed. Anybody else with the same problem? I can`t continue because it says, I must buy everything of the list before I could buy something other.

silver ink pot September 18th, 2011 8:47 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Annett (Post 5880634)
Hi everyone,

finally got into Beta, only to encounter a fairly nasty problem:

Spoiler: show
I`m in Diagon Alley, buying items of the shopping list. I followed the list, that anybody could see because all but the wand is crossed through. But if I look in my trunk, I have only 5 objects and exactly 5 books. My galleons budget is exactly as it should be after byuing all thats crossed out.
I waited a couple of days, nothing has changed. Anybody else with the same problem? I can`t continue because it says, I must buy everything of the list before I could buy something other.

Clear the temporary files and cookies in your computer. That way Pottermore will refresh to the correct view of the page when you go back to it. What you are seeing may be a frozen or outdated image.

AccioDragon102 September 18th, 2011 8:59 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Ugh. I still can't brew potions.

Spoiler: show

Why does it not show up as brewing after I've completed the first phase? I've tried like 5 times now. So disappointed, Pottermore.

ChaiWytch September 18th, 2011 9:10 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Annett (Post 5880634)
Hi everyone,

finally got into Beta, only to encounter a fairly nasty problem:

Spoiler: show
I`m in Diagon Alley, buying items of the shopping list. I followed the list, that anybody could see because all but the wand is crossed through. But if I look in my trunk, I have only 5 objects and exactly 5 books. My galleons budget is exactly as it should be after byuing all thats crossed out.
I waited a couple of days, nothing has changed. Anybody else with the same problem? I can`t continue because it says, I must buy everything of the list before I could buy something other.

I noticed the same thing. Not to worry.. They're not lost. :) One book goes to your Potions section, 2 to your Spells section.

Daggerstone September 18th, 2011 9:15 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AccioDragon102 (Post 5880666)
Ugh. I still can't brew potions.

Spoiler: show

Why does it not show up as brewing after I've completed the first phase? I've tried like 5 times now. So disappointed, Pottermore.

Same here. Plus, I've lost two cauldrons in the last 24 hours - hoe the Hell was I supposed to know that "2" means "four" in Pottermorespeak? :grumble:

Hes September 18th, 2011 9:18 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
I've had those problems as well so didn't waste time on potions this weekend. They have to fix quite a few bugs in Potions before I want to risk my cauldron again.

AccioDragon102 September 18th, 2011 9:22 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
At least we know we're not alone. Hopefully Pottermore is implementing a fix quickly.

Daggerstone September 18th, 2011 9:27 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
It's too late for me, Hes... I'm hooked! :lol:

A lot of people in Ravenclaw Common Room have been claiming same problems. Moderation's been working full-time, too...

threecats September 18th, 2011 9:38 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
I am having the various potions issues from time to time, and have found that a reboot usually fixes it. Microsoft. :rolleyes:

Annett September 18th, 2011 9:52 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ChaiWytch (Post 5880681)
I noticed the same thing. Not to worry.. They're not lost. :) One book goes to your Potions section, 2 to your Spells section.

Means everything is fine? :blush: Where can I find that Potions and Spells section?

And than there is another place for the cauldron too?

Thank you for your help!

And thanks SIP! I`ve tried that already, but nothing changed.

threecats September 18th, 2011 9:57 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Annett (Post 5880751)
Means everything is fine? :blush: Where can I find that Potions and Spells section?

And than there is another place for the cauldron too?

Thank you for your help!

And thanks SIP! I`ve tried that already, but nothing changed.

Spoiler: show
You will find your cauldron in the potions section later on. If everything on your list is crossed off, including the pet, there should be an arrow on the ground about half way down Diagon Alley pointing to the right. If you click on that, you get to the south side of DA, where you find Ollivanders.

Edit: Potions and spells are on the top of the screen, to the right of the Pottermore logo.

ChaiWytch September 18th, 2011 10:06 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Annett (Post 5880751)
Means everything is fine? :blush: Where can I find that Potions and Spells section?

And than there is another place for the cauldron too?

Thank you for your help!

And thanks SIP! I`ve tried that already, but nothing changed.

Spoiler: show
Yep! You're on track. :) Yep, Spells and Potions will be unlocked later. Also, all your cauldrons and ingredients are kept in the Potions sections too.

HPGirl7 September 18th, 2011 11:44 pm

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
How many people Are on currently, and can you check what day some of them got in on? Thanks! And ps, did anyone who got in on 5 th day get in yet?

StormBronze September 19th, 2011 12:25 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by HPGirl7 (Post 5880887)
How many people Are on currently, and can you check what day some of them got in on? Thanks! And ps, did anyone who got in on 5 th day get in yet?

You can read through here to find out:

http://www.cosforums.com/showthread....129944&page=77

MarauderIce39 September 19th, 2011 1:35 am

Re: Pottermore v.10
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RemusLupinFan (Post 5879118)
Spoiler: show
I accidentally dropped one of the Valerian sprigs on the counter one time when doing the Sleeping Draught, and it failed me. It told me I put the Valerian sprigs in the wrong container. So it does look like being messy can fail you. And that happened after I'd waited the 100 minutes. :grumble:

Regarding the heating, I've been able to get by fine with using the red button to heat up quickly, and then using the orange and off buttons to modulate the temperature.

Same happened to me with the VS and the SD, but I'm only ever told the reason for failure was that I put in too much Standard Ingredient, which I know has never occurred.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 4:48 am.

Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

Original content is Copyright © MMII - MMVIII, CoSForums.com. All Rights Reserved.
Other content (posts, images, etc) is Copyright © its respective owners.