NT #44 - The Crux of it All

[secretkeeper14]

Hey Maline, this is my first post on cos. I read your #44 'The Crux of it All'. I don't quite agree with the idea of Harry being a Horcrux.At least not the way you have suggested. "then he tried to kill harry and his soul split athird time????????? How?? Didn't Slughorn say quite clearly that you need to kill someone in order to split your soul... voldy didn't actually kill harry ,he tried .... but he failed. So his soul didNOT split 3 times. Also the finale of Ootp shows us that voldy couldn't stay inside harry(for afew seconds) even though at that time he had harry's blood running in his veins.So voldy's soul in harry at the time when his mother had died to save him and voldy couldn't even touch him is quite impossible.

[IZZIEPIXIE17]

Hi Maline !!i Think U Did A Great Job On This Editorial It Really Got Me Thinking About All The Distractions In Book 6 And Jk Repititions With A Twist .like The Major One Teacher Fools Dumbledore And Is Working For Voldemort .i Think Snape Was A Major Distraction In Book 6 Because I Think She Tried To Fool Us To Believing He Is Just Another Imposster But He Cant Be Because Thats Already Been Done To Death !!!anyway I Think U Have Got It Right With Harry Has Part Of Voldemorts Soul !i Think That His Scar Was An Opening And A Piece Of His Soul Went Inside His Head That Night The Connection Between Them Is Too Strong .i Think Dumbledore Knew This All Along Ever Since The Firth Book When Took Out That Smoke Thing And It Showed There Soul Combined And Lied To Harry To Protect Him Thinking That He Will Find Out Himself !! Izzie

[CplTaggart]

Maline, I would like to say that I have a piece of info that I believe helps your theory. I'm not sure if anyone else has said it, but I haven't seen it anywhere. On page 379 - 380 in HBP When Hermoine and Harry are talking with Hagrid, Hagrid says that Dumbledore had an argument with Snape; An argument in which he said that Snape had to do what he'd agreed and that there was no getting out of it. I personally believe Snape had told Dumbledore of the Unbreakable Vow, and as you said, Dumbledore knew he was dying. Dumbledore told Snape that is he must, he has to do it. Just an idea. That scene always intrigued me because it slipped in under the Radar so easily. I could be wrong. I'm not sure. Any reply would be awesome (E-mail or whatever, The_Legendary_Joker@Hotmail.com is my E-mail, but I'm not even sure if you still check on this site so.) Thanks in Advance for your attention to this matter.

[inkling7]

Don't worry a lot of people have worried about exactly the same thing - you are not alone as this conversation casts doubt on the loyalty - or lack of - of Snape. Did Albus know or did he not know that he was dying from the effects of the poton in the bowl in the cave??????