That "certain room" JKR mentioned

[jaedi]

I agree whizbang121. The kitchen is one of those rooms that I think would make sense for absolutely no reason! The chamberpot room is like that too to some people.

[whizbang121]

and who knows where house elves go when they go home for family reunions?

[jaedi]

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.......................

[Moony]

Well I read that theory somewhere on the chamber pot room... so don't give me credit for it. I also think it may be Professor Trelawneys room, because thats where she had the prediction of Voldemort. Also, thats where Harry say Buckbeak getting away (although it was mainly wishful thinking, he may of subconcensley predicted it). Maybe it really does have something to do with telling and future.
Also, as Muse said a few posts back, the cover of the book is circiular and has candles and sort of resembles it.

[Essbee]

Still plumbing for the Triz-wizard room.

Place your bets now...

It'll be really funny if it is in book 5, then those of us who were right can start a thread in the book 5 forum saying 'I told you so!'.

Does anyone know how long it's gonna be before we can discuss stuff from book 5 in the main forum?

[R3mus Lup!n]

I'm going for the chamberpot room.

[ahsweape]

Well I guess we definitely know which room she was referring to now.

[SiriusBlack13]

Umm it could be me.... but a new room in book 4 was the Prefects bathroom could that have anything to do with it?

[mystically_mad]

Originally posted by Essbee (original post)

Does anyone know how long it's gonna be before we can discuss stuff from book 5 in the main forum?

I know, I just want to *

[Emma]

If spoilers are posted the thread will be deleted...Please no spoilers of any kind...

There is to be abosolutely no unauthorized information from Order of the Phoenix in this forum. Anyone who posts spoilers--information revealing aspects of Book 5 not released by the publishers or JK Rowling--will recieve a serious warning and face possible banning from Chamber of Secrets forums.

This means that you may not post plot lines from Book 5 or theories based on Book 5 in this forum. After you have read the book, you may not post reviews of it here, or any other information that would let someone who had not read the book know what it contained.

In addition, please remember:


You may not post spoilers in any other forum with the exception of the soon-to-be-created Book 5 forums.


Spoilers in signatures and avatars are not allowed and will be removed. Such behavior carries a serious warning.


If you with to send a PM containing spoilers, obtain their permisssion first.


If in doubt, use the spoiler tag. Type [*Spoiler] (without the *) before the text in question, and [/spoiler] after it.

[PhoenixUK]

I'm guessing that the room we are talking about in this thread has been revealed in OOTP, and is being discussed at http://www.cosforums.com/showthread....threadid=11351 .

** This thread is in the BOOK 5 AREA and so contains SPOILERS! **

[mystically_mad]

Finally, somewhere we can talk about it.

[Amadeus]

The only room that would be eligible to be a favourite room would be the room of requirement.

[mystically_mad]

Hey if I were you I would delete that post. You arent allowed to post anything from the OOTP in here.

[Essbee]

Hey, Mystically_Mad! Gosh, I've been gone a while again, haven't I?

Anyway, I'd like to say which of us was right... but you know... <grovel>

[hermione_fan]

I think it's the room with all the chamber pots. Maybe the room of requirement is that same room.

[Essbee]

Yes Hermione_fan, I think so, but I don't think you're allowed to say that... I'd edit it out if I were you so the mods don't get annoyed.