Regulus Black the First?

[blaqlives]

Discussion of the editorial Regulus Black the First? by Rowena&Salazar4ever.

[Liselle]

Please remember that the COS Forums conduct notice is in full swing here also

COS Forums Conduct notice Welcome one and all to the Deathly Hallows Discussion Forum. So, now that the final book is here, you may all begin your discussion of the story that we've all been waiting for. general notice of conduct, zero tolerance & fan submitted work This icon is the report button. It appears in every post someone makes. Use it when you feel it needs using. Spoiler Policy There is a general two-month ban on discussing DH outside of this area. We will lift the ban on September 24th. The date is subject to change. Anyone caught posting Spoilers outside the Deathly Hallows area will be subject to a three-point warning if they have been a member for longer than 30 days. For members under the 30-day period, they will be issued with a one-point warning. Second offences will result in an instant banning for either group. No one may include spoilers in their signature, avatar or anywhere in their profiles. This instruction lasts for 45 days from the day of this thread creation. The 45 days are subject to change, either an increase or decrease. Use of the Wizengamot for questions related to the Deathly Hallows discussion area is prohibited. Please use the High Inquisitor's Chamber. General Conduct Members are requested to moderate their tone and be sensitive to those whose theories are proven inaccurate or altogether, wrong. Regardless of the personal gratification you may take in being proven right, you will not last more than ten seconds as a member here and will be forgotten several seconds after we have banned you, if, you decide to act out your pleasure on here. Private Conduct If you are in receipt of a private message (Owl) where a member conducts themselves in a manner similar to the General Conduct notice above, you may forward such an owl onto a member of staff and we will action it accordingly. If you fake such a message we will know and you will be banned. If the message is genuine, we will warn/ban the member involved depending on the severity. I would like to point out that a heated argument is not the same as a blatant poke with the 'you're wrong' stick. Private Messages are there for you to engage in conversation that may get heated, that would normally be removed on public forums. If you yourself have engaged or baited the person into saying something, you won't get very far if you report it to us. Additionally, please inform us if you receive spam messages of any kind, in particular people spoiling the book. Fanfiction & Art All fan submissions related to the Deathly Hallows must be made in their relevant areas "Flourish & Blotts - New Premises" and "Hallowed Masterpieces" and any subforums within them. You may not post them outside the area. You may not link them in your signature. More on that below. Signatures, Profiles etc... No book 7 related information maybe included in your signature until after the spoiler policy is over. That means you may not have avatars, signatures or link threads of importance in the Deathly Hallows area in your profile/signature. If you do so, you will have the links removed and be warned.

As always forum rules apply. If anyone has any questions, please feel free to contact a staff member Better to ask the question than be proven wrong.

[You_Know_Pooh]

i knew that thjis had no chance of being right, mainly because it was all "if" startements and was backed up by very lttle or no proof

[ChudleyCannon23]

I think it was brilliant analysis, you really did your research. It does seem like it could have certainly been true. I would have to look over some stuff before I call it fact, like for instance some of Kreachers memories of "master Regulus". The statement I most question was when you said that you doubt an 18 old boy would know what a horcrux is or how to destroy it because Regulus came from a dark enough family that he could have found out and if my memory is correct, he didn't destroy it. I can't say that I'm convinced because throughout the book it lead you so strongly to assume it was Sirius's brother, but kudos to a strong argument that deserves a little looking into.