Teddy Lupin and the parallel to Harry

[Yavien]

What so you think of this.
Ted+s parents were killed by Voldemort (maybe not directly, but sureley because of him), as were Harry's.
Ted only has a godfather that fought Voldemort and had a slose connenction with his parents, as Harry had Sirius who was very close to Lily and James.
Ted is (as I could point out from the Deathly Hallows) a metamorphmagus and that was an extraordinary thing, as Harry has a scar which was also something different from what other people had.
These things make me wonder.... what do you think??

Im sad that no one is interested in this theme. It is obvious that J. K. Rowling wanted to make someone that was similar to harry and i cant believe no one would want to discuss this..

[Oopie]

I think she definately tried to make someone similiar, and i definately felt that when Lupin and Tonks showed up on the night of the battle that atleast one of them would die. All of this especially after Harry was made his godfather. There is definately a relationship between the two except that Ted was able to grow up in the wizarding world. This knowledge is already an edge on Harry, and i bet Ted will be just as successful.

[sweets7]

Teddy was very similar to both Harry and Neville, but he served as a foil to them. His parents were killed when he was a baby, but unlike Harry and Neville, who had to fight for love, security, self - worth and acceptance; Teddy always had it. I mean the description of him in the epilogue indicated that he was everything his parents would have wished: secure, loved, confident. His presence really indicated that the world was now a happier place and free from the darkness suffered by the previous generation.

[FanofLupin]

Yeah, it was definitely a parallel. She even said it was in her Today Show interview.

[xoxtapdancexox]

Originally Posted by Yavien

What so you think of this.
Ted+s parents were killed by Voldemort (maybe not directly, but sureley because of him), as were Harry's.
Ted only has a godfather that fought Voldemort and had a slose connenction with his parents, as Harry had Sirius who was very close to Lily and James.
Ted is (as I could point out from the Deathly Hallows) a metamorphmagus and that was an extraordinary thing, as Harry has a scar which was also something different from what other people had.
These things make me wonder.... what do you think??

Im sad that no one is interested in this theme. It is obvious that J. K. Rowling wanted to make someone that was similar to harry and i cant believe no one would want to discuss this..

that's true...
but isn't his grandmother alive?? which...in a way...is sort of like Nevielle too???

[Voldemorts8thHorcrux]

Unlike Harry, his godfather didn't spent 13 years in Azkaban or out of his life and he actually has a grandmother.

[rhhgrt]

Im sad that no one is interested in this theme. It is obvious that J. K. Rowling wanted to make someone that was similar to harry and i cant believe no one would want to discuss this..

Actually Teddy is more of a foil to Harry than anything else. Teddy is raised by a loving grandmother with an involved godfather and multiple close family friends. Teddy is very much the anti-Harry/Neville (since I doubt that Augusta was a very nurturing woman).

[Yavien]

Originally Posted by rhhgrt

Teddy is very much the anti-Harry/Neville (since I doubt that Augusta was a very nurturing woman).

But the thing that hes anti Harry/Neville also means that he resembles them. Only in some different way.
I decided to put this thread because I was very glad to see that there could be another Harry and I cried at this point of the book, because I remembered what was like when I first read the Philospohers Stone and thought what would the ending be.
And I cried because I would like to read a stroy about Ted Lupin and his school mates, and that was not possible. I only hope I will get to some really good fan fic.

[sweets7]

Originally Posted by Yavien

But the thing that hes anti Harry/Neville also means that he resembles them. Only in some different way.

It is true that his situation did parallel Harry and Neville, but he really seemed to be a completely different person to them. In fact it sounded like he was very much in the mould of the marauders (without the arrogance and bullying of James and Sirius). It is funny because there was such a short description of him in the epilogue and it sounded like he was a complete mixture of both parents and was everything, they would have wished for him.

[dobby_rocks]

Well Teddy wasn’t really that similar to Harry. Sure they have things in common both were orphaned at a young age. But Teddy unlikely Harry who grew up in a neglectfully home not knowing that he was a wizard, nor anything about his parents other then the story the Dursleys made up. While Teddy being raised by his grandmother as well as having Harry, and other Order members in his life. Who’d answer any question he had about Lupin and Tonks. Teddy had love and always knew it. You could also threw Neville in this comparison since he too was raised by his grandmother, but she was always for the longest time making comparisons between Neville and his dad, so Neville probably felt at times he wasn’t good enough grandson or son. .

Some parallels yes but when you look at it Teddy had a far better life then Neville, or Harry had. Well as good as your life can be having lost your parents at such a young age.

[Yavien]

Originally Posted by dobby_rocks

Some parallels yes but when you look at it Teddy had a far better life then Neville, or Harry had. Well as good as your life can be having lost your parents at such a young age.

I perfectly agree. And I think this is a part of the message Rowling wanted to send to us. That without You-Know-Who world is a better place for those who had the same fate as Harry and Neville, to be separated from their parents at such young age.

[uptownsquirrel]

As soon as Harry was named Ted Lupin's godfather, I knew that Lupin and Tonks were going to die just like Harry's parents died. It is the same type of story again without Voldemort and all the Horcuxes. My only question is: Is Harry going to die in a battle just like Sirius died?

[rhhgrt]

Yavien posted:

But the thing that hes anti Harry/Neville also means that he resembles them. Only in some different way.

Yeah, he's a foil to them.

[natrod311]

I thought it was terrible that his parents died, and I really think it was not 100% necessary, I mean, not everything has to have a parallel.
Hey, at least he has a hot girlfriend though!

[Evil_Voldemort]

Hi. It's sad that Ted lost his parents like Harry did. But he wasn't attacked by Voldemort like Harry was when he was one years old and lives in the world without Voldemort.

[Clareious]

Originally Posted by uptownsquirrel

My only question is: Is Harry going to die in a battle just like Sirius died?

I don't think so. I think Jo made it pretty clear that the world is a much happier place now. THe point of the parallels isn't for history to repeat itself, it's to show how much things had changed.
Harry Potter - orphaned shortly after birth, brought up by neglectful and uncaring relatives, didn't see his godfather for 13 years, deprived of love.
Teddy Lupin - orphaned shortly after birth, brought up by a loving grandmother and with a lot of access to his godfather and extended family, clearly loved and respected.
I think Harry himself would have recognised the parallels and ensured that Teddy Lupin had the kind of childhood he would have wished for himself.

[Yavien]

Originally Posted by uptownsquirrel

. My only question is: Is Harry going to die in a battle just like Sirius died?

No! Definitely no. Because Sirius was meant to die. He proved Harry he was good, and that he always loved him and when he did that he was at peace. And he didnt cared about his life anymore, he just wanted to protect Harry. And you know what happened to all who protected Harry. His parents, Dumbledore, Sirius... and Severus... all dead...

[Yavien]

Is there someone who can say something more about this topic. Im all into discussion about this.

[skedaddle]

There is a power of three in that statement. Teddy was extremely similar to both Harry and Neville in this situation, growing up with no parents because of the same man. However, I think that Harry and Teddy are a lot more similar, and will share a bond over what happened early in their lives forever. I believe that JKR wrote the storyline of Teddy into the books to show a parallel in Harry's life to someone else for a change. No one in the series thus far knows what its like to lose both parents besides Neville, but to now have the responsibility to watch over someone who went through the same stuff that you did is very hard to do. JKR brought Harry's story full circle; giving him parental figures/new parents (Remus and Tonks) and then disposing of them in a quick and heartbreaking way.

[Fairygdmther]

Despite all the literary references and plot devices, it gave Harry a way to pay back to some of those who helped him when he had no one to turn to.

No one knew better than Harry that a child without love could become the next Voldemort rather than a good person like Neville or himself. From 11 on, Harry received love and support when he needed it most. And he knew that this helped him to make the right choices. He made sure that Teddy and his own kids would never want for love.

FGM