The All Inclusive HBP Thread v11

[AccioHP]

That youtube video was amazing!

[Montse]

Originally Posted by AccioHP

That youtube video was amazing!

I agree, I even was laughing about the delay!!

Dont take me wrong , I think the delay sucks ,but this video shows it under suck comic light , it makes you smile about it. It works as a catharsis.

[Joga_Bonito]

Do you think the movie will do a god job about letting it be known Ron doesnt think he's good enough for Hermione so thats why he does nothing..and the incident of her attributing his good performance due to the lucky potion and finding out shes already kissed someone will be what makes him give up and just "settle" for someone who appreciates him as he is?

Or do you think they changed atleast part of that? I havent heard much about this yet, so curious.

[deansboy]

Originally Posted by Joga_Bonito

Do you think the movie will do a god job about letting it be known Ron doesnt think he's good enough for Hermione so thats why he does nothing..and the incident of her attributing his good performance due to the lucky potion and finding out shes already kissed someone will be what makes him give up and just "settle" for someone who appreciates him as he is?

Or do you think they changed atleast part of that? I havent heard much about this yet, so curious.

Thats a kind of depth that'd drown the people who make these films. They'll just tell that in a fart joke.

[Montse]

Originally Posted by Joga_Bonito

Do you think the movie will do a god job about letting it be known Ron doesnt think he's good enough for Hermione so thats why he does nothing..and the incident of her attributing his good performance due to the lucky potion and finding out shes already kissed someone will be what makes him give up and just "settle" for someone who appreciates him as he is?

The films in my opinion have been throwing hints about the Ron/Hermione thing. Now, about how Ron feels about himself, I think and imagine will be clearly shown until we have DH when he destroys the locket.Until then , I can imagine they will just show they have feelings for each other but none of them does anything about them. That is how I see them approaching it.

[arithmancer]

Originally Posted by CountWestwest

That's exactly what I was thinking... no Slug Club in the train... but how does Harry get into the Slytherin compartment if he is not following Blaise?

He decides to spy on Draco, just because he is suspicious based on the Diagon Alley scenes. It would not be the first time. (CoS).

[Montse]

Originally Posted by zgirnius

He decides to spy on Draco, just because he is suspicious based on the Diagon Alley scenes. It would not be the first time. (CoS).

Yes, but how does he get in without being noticed. We know in the book, he takes advantage of Zabini going in. I suppose they will have to make someone enter the compartment. As simple as that, but I wish they could come up with something better than that.

[deansboy]

Originally Posted by zgirnius

He decides to spy on Draco, just because he is suspicious based on the Diagon Alley scenes. It would not be the first time. (CoS).

CoS he wasn't suspicious he got stuck and they came in there's a difference.

[DeathlyH]

Originally Posted by zgirnius

He decides to spy on Draco, just because he is suspicious based on the Diagon Alley scenes. It would not be the first time. (CoS).

That would actually work. Another thing I wonder about: will McClaggen be in the film?

[arithmancer]

Originally Posted by Montse

Yes, but how does he get in without being noticed. In the book, we know in the book, he takes advantage of Zabini going in. I suppose they will have to make someone enter the compartment. As simple as that, but I wish they could come up with something better thatn that.

If Draco does not skip out of it, he could be returning with Pansy from the Prefects' car. He could walk by and say something rude, giving Harry the idea to follow (I seem to recall he actually does this in the book). Harry could follow in the wake of the candy lady and sneak in while Crabbe and Goyle stock up on goodies. It's not hard to think up reasons.

Originally Posted by deansboy

CoS he wasn't suspicious he got stuck and they came in there's a difference.

I refer to the elaborate plot to make Polyjuice in order to impersonate Crabbe and Goyle in order to grill Draco about the Heir of Slytherin. That was no accident.

[Montse]

Originally Posted by DeathlyH

McClaggen be in the film?

cough*HBP list *cough

[ArryGrotter]

Originally Posted by DeathlyH

That would actually work. Another thing I wonder about: will McClaggen be in the film?

He is

Originally Posted by Montse

cough*HBP list *cough

*coughs violently too*

[Montse]

Originally Posted by zgirnius

arry could follow in the wake of the candy lady and sneak in while Crabbe and Goyle stock up on goodies. It's not hard to think up reasons.

Yeah , it could be. I suppose it could work.I still find it easier to think it would be easier if he followed someone like in the book.Specially since we cannot see what Harry is doing when he has the cloak on, it might be hard to show what happened...I think .I am having trouble picturing it. But , that could be cause I stick to stuff as it was in books.

[arithmancer]

In the movies we can see Harry under the cloak. They do those shots from "inside" where we see what Harry sees, as though through a thin cloth. I think they would need to do this as Harry passes into the compartment and climbs on the luggage rack, regardless of the reason Harry came, so that we could see Harry see Draco look up suspiciously as a trainer sticks out for a moment, and then seemingly dismiss his concern.

[MAGICicalMUggle]

Originally Posted by phoenix88

How are we ever going to wait again over these next 11 months? At this rate, we will probably have the whole movie in the form of pics and scripts by then



You summarized my feelings perfectly! The posted you tube video was hilarious! They should send it to the WB!! Thanks for the link.

I hope i'll be able to make it until then thats if the stress of the delay won't kill me!...lol, I would have liked the entire movie to be a surprise but i guess i could live with reading a couple of scripts!....And i bet all the pics we will be getting we could stack them all togather than create a moving picture book movie or somthing!...


Thanks Phoenix!....I knew everyone would like the vid!...laughter is the best medicine after all!...



i'm glad you enjoyed it too AccioHP and Montse!

[CountWestwest]

Originally Posted by ArryGrotter

Harry/Ginny:    

---

Yay! More arguement over whether it's adream or not....

I must have missed the whole "is it dream or not" discussion and have seen you mention that discussion several times... but in the book Harry's dreams seemed to have been of a more intense sexual nature, since he was thankful Ron wasn't a legilimens. The scene in the Sneak Peak and this photo there isn't even a "holding sweaty hands together" moment... which is why I think it's not a dream. I understand they want to keep the movie PG, but this is way too bland and seems for a G movie.

My only doubt is because of the way Ginny walks away in a sad sort of way (I'm sure that point was discussed) which could mean an "angst" filled dream by Harry or perhaps since they redid Dumbledore's funeral, this is the break-up.

Edit: In reality it is Harry the one who should "walk away" because it is symbolic of him being the one breaking the relationship.

[JustAnIllusion]

Originally Posted by lindaluna

McCrory looks really old in that skunk head picture. Isn't she in her 20's ?

I realize it's a still, but she looks like she's overacting too.

She looks way older than Bellatrix, IMO. She also looks like she could be older than her hubby

[MAGICicalMUggle]

Originally Posted by JustAnIllusion

She looks way older than Bellatrix, IMO. She also looks like she could be older than her hubby

LOL your right about that!...Even Mcgonagall looks younger than Narcissa!..




Here's another funny Vid i found on youtube about the HBP being delayed!...It's quite clever!...I like the line Harry gives..."clearly somebody doesn't want me here this year"


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2ThAXJDyZU
i'll make sure to add more links to my sig if i find more!...

[Montse]

Originally Posted by CountWestwest

I must have missed the whole "is it dream or not" discussion and have seen you mention that discussion several times... but in the book Harry's dreams seemed to have been of a more intense sexual nature, since he was thankful Ron wasn't a legilimens. The scene in the Sneak Peak and this photo there isn't even a "holding sweaty hands together" moment... which is why I think it's not a dream. I understand they want to keep the movie PG, but this is way too bland and seems for a G movie.

I recall having this discussion with Scott. Cause I understood the same you did David. However , I dont think is a dream and that they are having it Shown as a G dream. I think it is the break up scene. I hope it is the break up scene. I dont want this to be THE Kiss scene, as I have previously said.

I agree Harry should be the one to walk away. If it is this scene. It should be like that. Harry walking away.

It could also be another moment. The shoelace scene, I dont think , but any other made up moment to build the romantic tension in between them.

[meesha1971]

Originally Posted by Montse

That is what I was thinking.I have no idea how they will do that.We know they will have that bit.We have scenes and all. Its puzzling...
I know David! I sooo wanted this scene in the film. Maybe it could happen before this scene. It could still be included...(hopeful thinking)
Then we get to see Dean /Ginny moments to hear out loud Ron expressing Harry´s thoughts.Could be , couldn´t it. I really want that scene in. I really , trully do.

It could still be in. In reading the leaked script for the Three Broomsticks scene, it appears to me that they might be playing around with the order of events with the Harry/Ginny stuff. And that makes sense because so much was cut regarding Ginny from the previous movies, they have to establish her as a character as well as build up the relationship. So it seems that they might be moving things along a bit faster for the movie. I think they will still need to work in the argument between Ron and Ginny because it plays into Ron starting to date Lavender.

They might have moved the initial Slug Club meeting from the train, but I wouldn't rule it out just yet. The picture of Ginny arriving at the dinner party looks to me more that she is late rather than anyone being surprised that she is there. I still think it will be a nice Harry/Ginny moment though. Even if he knows she is coming, his reaction to seeing her all dressed up will be good.

OMG! OMG! OMG!
"Don´t worry Harry I am with you " line is there. I had so not noticed in my frustration!
*dances to celebrate*
I so wanted this line to be in.

I knew they wouldn't cut that line.

Originally Posted by ArryGrotter

He is



*coughs violently too*

Would you like a cough drop, ArryGrotter?