Would you rather! v.2

[WelkinCooper]

Originally Posted by merrymarge

would you rather spend time with Lupin in the shrieking shack with a full moon, or with Sirius at Grimauld place.

I'll go with Sirius, since I'm not feeling even remotely foolhardy or suicidal tonight.

Would you rather wear a long flowing cloak or a pointy witch's hat when you go to the grocery?

[merrymarge]

Well, a long flowing cloak will cover most anything, while a witch's hat will just cover my head.

Woulld you rather dance the tango with Peeves or Kreacher?

[WelkinCooper]

Originally Posted by merrymarge

Woulld you rather dance the tango with Peeves or Kreacher?

I'll dance with Peeves.

Would you rather have your hand kissed by a Goblin or Lucius Malfoy?

[merrymarge]

Lucius, only he would have to be quick so Narcissa doesn't see him.

would you rather go shopping with Umbridge or Hagrid?

[KatiePotterHead]

Mr. Rubeus Hagrid FTW

hmmm Would you rather sit thru a lesson in Professor Binn's boring class or sit thru a lesson with one of the Carrows teaching?

[SirDobster]

Sit through a lessons with Binns. The Carrows are scary.

Would you rather be caught by Filch or Umbridge, when doing something sneaky.

[merrymarge]

Filch of course, he is all "bark and no bite", Umbridge is the opposite.

Would you rather sit in the top box at the Quidditch World Cup or lower down?

[SirDobster]

The Top Box. It'd give me a bit of vertigo, but it'd be fun.

If you were participating in Qudditch, would you rather use the Wronski Feint or the Sloth Grip Roll?

[merrymarge]

I think the Sloth Grip Roll. Wronski Feint sounds too risky for me.

would you rather dance the polka with Uncle Vernon, or play the bagpipes with Prof. McGonagall?

[Kalu98132]

Play the bagpipes with McGonagall

Would you rather have Uncle Vernon be your father or Lucius Melfoy

[WelkinCooper]

Originally Posted by Kalu98132

Would you rather have Uncle Vernon be your father or Lucius Melfoy

Lucius Malfoy - It would be fun rattling around in that cavernous manor house, except when Voldemort was there.

Whose godmother/godfather would you rather be - Harry Potter's or Hermione Granger's?

[snugglepot]

Harry's, of course.

Would you rather write in Riddle's diary or wear the locket Horcrux?

[WelkinCooper]

Originally Posted by snugglepot

Would you rather write in Riddle's diary or wear the locket Horcrux?

I'd rather write in Tom Riddle's diary: "Dear Diary, today I met the man of my dreams. He invited me to the Founder's Feast and said not to be alarmed if he shows up to escort me, accompanied by a very large snake. I wonder what he meant by that?"

Would you rather have coffee and tea cakes with Remus Lupin, or tea and coffee cake with Albus Dumbledore? Or would you rather ditch both of them and have a nice medium rare steak and a baked potato with Severus Snape?

[merrymarge]

Let see, start with tea and coffee cake with Dumbledore. Later, rare steak and baked potato with Severus.
What? Only allowed one choice?!! well, I will stick with tea and coffee cake with Dumbledore.

would you rather pose for a portrait to hang in Hogwarts or take magical pictures?

[WelkinCooper]

Originally Posted by merrymarge

would you rather pose for a portrait to hang in Hogwarts or take magical pictures?

I'd pose for the portrait. Either very scantily clad or wearing a Hawaiian shirt and rose-colored sunglasses.

Would you rather design and construct a parade float for your House at Hogwarts, or ride on the float all around Hogsmeade?

[merrymarge]

I want to ride on the float and wave. I am not able to make a float without making a mess of things.

would you rather go to Hogwarts in a flying car or a regular Muggle car, that stays on the road?

[WelkinCooper]

Originally Posted by merrymarge

would you rather go to Hogwarts in a flying car or a regular Muggle car, that stays on the road?

I'll take the flying car. Not all of the Muggle ones stay on the road, and some of them seem to fly even if they do stay on the road (like the ones my sister-in-law drives).

Would you rather listen to Flitwick's choir sing old Madonna tunes, or listen to Severus Snape sing a selection from Phantom of the Opera?

[merrymarge]

I'll try the old Madonna tunes, because I can't stand opera.
I looked at what I wrote and for a minute I thought I wrote Ol' Mcdonald tunes!! e-e-i, e-e-i, o!

would you rather try your hand at making new potions or new charms?

[WelkinCooper]

Originally Posted by merrymarge

would you rather try your hand at making new potions or new charms?

New charms...

Would you rather duel against Draco or against Harry Potter?

[sparrowinwinter]

Against Draco.

Would you rather have a dragon or a giant three headed dog?