H/L - Why I Became a Harry/Luna Shipper

[navygreen]

Discussion for the Madam Puddifoot's H/L article - Why I Became a Harry/Luna Shipper by Jenna.

[Corbin Dallas]

A good article and I like Jenna's reasons, personally I like chocolate but there are some excellent points in this article, we'll just have to see if Luna herself is into Harry or his story...
CD
again, good article

[puffin]

I can see Jenna's point but, personally, I think that Luna is important to Harry as a good friend. I just can't see him taking her seriously as a romantic interest. She's great as a friend and she has great qualities but I don't think that the way she's been described so far is romantic in any way. And don't forget that we're seeing things through Harry's eyes. I get the impression that she's just a friend to him and nothing more, and this editorials arguments didn't quite persuade me (although it was a very good editorial).
Just my opinion

[Lupin27]

Hell, if I were Harry, I'd have asked Luna out a long time ago. But, then, I'm not Harry and I've had a serious Luna crush for a while...

[corriebird]

I don't think harry respects luna enough to become serious with her. I think it would take a longer amount of time than two years (or even one) to consider her girlfriend material. he only starts being comforted by her, and accepting what she says as possibility at the very end. remember how, when she told him she saw thestrals too, he was quicker to assume HE was going nuts rather than taking what she said as the truth? its going to take more time to develop a real friendship with her. and even then... his worries are based so much in the real world, his immidiate future has possible death written all over it.... I dont think harry'll be very impressed with Crumple-Horned Snorkacks.

[meg2089kul]

For some reason, I've always thought of h/l as in a brotherly-sisterly sort of relationship, despite my ships. Let's not focus on that for now. The reason for this is that 1. We don't see Harry interested in her in any manner. If you notice, Harry didn't really seem to care whatsoever when Luna fell over in the DoM. In fact, all he does with her is...talk. Much philosophically. 2. He's grateful for her kindness and he feels comfortable talking to her only because she's been through something similar to him. However, so has Susan Bones. That doesn't mean that she should be immediately considered as a love interest. I do, neverthelss, strongly stand by the idea that Luna will play a very important role, only not that of romance. If we talk about romance, then I simply cannot doubt that Luna likes Ron. In JKR's words: "It's easy to love Ron - but so obivious."
But I do like Luna, even though she is a bit touched in the head. I think that the quarrels with Hermione about her insane ideas are quite hilarious and that it will definitely give them all something to think about, but definitely not a love interest of Harry's. Harry needs someone who understands him (practically reads him), has been loyal to him, and someone who knows what it's like to have been with him from the beginning. Whether that means my ship or not, I personally cannot say, but that is purely my opinion. I only see Luna as an inspiration for Harry to give things a little faith and hope for the best. Maybe he will take her advice, and I sure hope so because I'll bet you more than anything, she'll have some answers for him to solving some of the most difficult questions in his life. I see Luna as Harry's tutor or mentor, as in a wise friend, and nothing more. As a matter of fact, I think that Luna is a lot smarter than they give her credit for and I just can't wait to learn what she's really got up her sleeve!

[Nicole99]

While this article makes some good points, all of these reasons can be attributed to a good, solid friendship, not neccessarily a romance. I don't see anything romantic between Harry and Luna in OotP, but I believe that she can relate to him well. Wouldn't the Ravenclaws still not steal Luna's stuff if she was in Harry's inner circle, as a close confidant? She doesn't have to be his LI for them to benefit from knowing each other.

[IrishPhoenix711]

Hey! This is Jenna the author. I enjoyed reading all of your thoughts on the editorial.

Anyway - I literally stumbled upon my new found ship only a few hours ago. I had been quite torn over who Harry was going to end up with.

Remember I'm considering not only the facts at hand, but the information that Jo gave us saying that Harry will have some romance, and by process of elimination, I see Luna as most likely.

Hermione and Harry, in my opinion, could never work as a romantic couple, for reasons I touched on in the editorial [believe me, I could rant for hours on this topic]
Ginny has moved on, and judging from what we're seeing from her now, Harry would really have to work to get romantically involved with her, she can't just let him back in. Harry has other things to worry about besides trying to win Ginny's affection.

No, he didn't show any interest in Luna the way through OotP- but like I said, it's not about attraction. He hasn't shown attraction towards Hermione or Ginny either. Yes, he shows concern, but that's because he's known them for five years. [Ginny closer to four, but she is Ron's sister]

As for Susan Bones having something in common with him - it's totally different. He can feel a connection with many people, but the one thing that has brought out the most explosive and complex emotional reaction we have ever seen, pushing even the prospect of 'kill or be killed' to the lower shelf on Harry's to do list is the death of Sirius. And THAT is what he can relate to Luna with, THAT is how she comforts him, making her bond with him stronger than anything someone else can possibly offer.

[queenofmod]

I ship H/Hr normally, and at the end of the day, that's still the ship I want the most.

I will say that after reading OotP I knew I would be satisfied by H/L. This editorial, and your comment Jenna, is the best reasoning I've read yet as to why Harry and Luna would be a good couple. I really liked your ideas on how Harry could benefit Luna. I think she stands as the most likely (among Luna, Ginny, and Hermione) to gain from a relationship with Harry.

I could see Harry and Luna together in book 6, even though I think/hope it will end with H/Hr.

[thprophecymaker]

Hermione is like Harry's older sister. She makes sure he doesn't do anything stupid, she goes along with his plans sometimes. Sure, they love each other, but that's natural between friends. You can have a sibling and want to bop them into last week but deep down, you still gotta love 'em. They're completely platonic.
Ron and Hermione, now they're something else. They've got that same relationship, but it's got more dimensions. For example:
- Ron being jealous when Hermione goes to the Yule Ball w/ Viktor
- Hermione being furious when Fleur kisses Ron
- The whole hand-holdy thing in the movie (if it wasn't true, JKR wouldn't have let them put it in)
- Ron and Hermione's bickering reminding Harry of Mr. and Mrs. Weasley...
- THE FACT THAT JKR HERSELF IS SORTA kinda a R/Hr shipper...
Yeah, lotsa stuff there. But this is about Harry and Luna, so here's some things that support the happy couple:
- Luna getting her daddy to publish Harry's interview in the Quibbler
- Harry's feeling of not-good...ness being lessened by his talk w/ Luna. It takes a lot to pick someone up after the death of a loved one. Luna must have some sort of ability that cheers people up. Either that, or there's something there.
- Harry feeling sorry for Luna. And offering to help her find her stuff. He hasn't known the girl for very long, but she's been a good friend. If there's one reason I can't get a lot of stuff on Luna and Harry, it's 'cause she really hasn't been around for long. Not much canon to support my theory. That, and I can't find a way to say what I'm thinking. Much too complex. Emotions are pretty hard to describe. But JKR does a good job at it, so gold star for her.

[scooterbug8515]

I liked Luna from the moment I met her. I think that she is my favorite female character. The Twins are my all time favorite characters. But alas I digress. I think I like Luna so well is because I relate to her. Since I like her so well, I have wanted her to be in a relationship with either Harry or Ron. As I read I got the feeling at time that Luna liked Harry and then at other times that she liked Ron. I am a BIG R/Hr shipper, I've been waiting for it since about book three. That then leaves a H/L relationship. In all honesty, it took me a long time for me to accept the idea of a H/G relationship so I think my current favorite ships are as follows:
R/Hr
H/L
G/Nevil or G/Collin (my preferance is Nevil)
Thank's Jenna for the wonderful article!

EDIT: I forgot to metion, that there wasn't any obvious romance in Ootp but romance can blossom fairly quickly! I can see a romance happening in HBP but not right off it would take of it of time before it happens in HBP. At the least, it could deffinatly happen at the end of HBP leaving the bulk of the romance to the 7th book.

[Oriel]

The Harry/Luna ship has always been one that I've supported so I'm glad there's an editorial about it. Although I think Harry will most likely end up with Ginny (which is unfortunate because I don't really like her for entirely personal and retarded reasons) I just can't stop hoping he will end up with her! I thoroughly enjoyed this editorial, and you pointed some things out that I've thought of before and unfortunately not eloquent enough to put into words...

[Shadow Phoenix]

I supported Harry and Luna since the 5th book. Their really good for each other. But from what I read H/L shippers seem to be a minority. I also support Ron and Hermione.

[MissingOctober]

Well, you know, I just don't see Harry with Luna. Call me mad, but finding some one odd and a bit of a loony is not a bit of a turn on, lol. I think Harry respects her, but he's not really into her in that way. I see him going elsewhere instead of with Luny Lovegood.

[scooterbug8515]

Sorry, but I have to stand in defence of Luna. I don't think that she is luny. She is unique, original, and sometimes (actualy many times) missunderstood. I think it makes her unique. She seems to me to be one of those people who blevies in the extraordinary and so many people mis-read it for crazyness (lunnieness (Is that a word?)). I still like Harry and Luna together I think they fit. The seem to understand eachother well.

[IceKat55]

Well written & thought out, Jenna! I ship Luna as a second choice for Harry, should Ginny not be the first. She has one very important scene with Harry in OotP that made me like her very much - - she can relate to his grief over the loss of Sirius, and she helped him to realize that life can, and will, go on without him. I'm still rooting for Ginny, but I do like the idea of Harry/Luna as well!

Again, well done!!

I honestly don't think that there will be a H/Hr romance (based on what JKR said and my own interpretation of events in OotP) but I think there is some pretty strong evidence in the books of either a H/L or a H/G relationship.
I think in order for Luna to be 'the one' for Harry, we're going to have to see some major character development in the next two books. I myself am currently not comfortable with her dating him. It sounds dorky, but I feel rather protective of him when it comes down to it.
After reading this article, I sat down to think about it for a few minutes and decided that it wouldn't be upsetting necessarily if Harry didn't end up with Ginny (I'll still root for her though!)... but I would like to know some positive things about Luna before I accepted her. We already know she's brave and loyal but her oddities are outweighing those good characteristics. So, I hope to see more of her in the future and if she's what Harry needs then more power to her!

[danni_shez]

I really liked the article! But I do have to disagree with it. I find that Harry's feelings towards Luna at the end of OoTP are those of pity. I can't see Harry developing a relationship with a person simply because he feels sorry for them. I think the fact that he can relate to her (in feeling like an outcast of sorts) will create a very strong friendship, but nothing more.
Thanks for the great article, though Jenna!

[dhaney]

I like this editorial. Personally, I'm a H/L shipper, though I have no problem if Harry end up with another girl, as long as WE like her. Anyway, Harry dating Luna could be interesting. I mean, Luna could give Harry a break as well as give him some insights and objective views on things. Luna is obviously a bright girl, being in Ravenclaw and all, but her loonyness is covering that. Maybe they'll talk about some incidents or certain person then Luna will utter something really ridiculous but equally right. (I'm a big Luna fan. )

And I don't think Ginny got over Harry yet. I think she is showing everyone that she is because she is kinda embarrassed that Harry didn't return her feelings (he like Cho instead). I mean everyone knows she likes Harry, even Harry, yet nothing happens, so she turns her attention to other boys but, maybe, secretly still like Harry. She has her pride afterall.

[LaceyCrane]

I really liked this editorial. It brought up some good points about Harry and Luna's relationship. But I just can't imagine them as a couple not just because she's to young for him ( a year in school is a big deal, for me at least) but because they barley know each other and since they are in different houses and won't be having any classes together there aren't very many opportunities for them to get to know each other. There might be potential for a relationship but not as much opportunity for it.